13 Top Cheeses At Trader Joe’s You Can’t Miss (Don’t Shop Without This List)

Trader Joe’s offers a delightful assortment of cheeses that cater to every palate. Whether you’re crafting a charcuterie board or enhancing your favorite dish, their selection promises quality and flavor. Here’s a curated list of must-try cheeses on your next shopping trip.

1. Unexpected Cheddar

Renowned for its unique flavor, Unexpected Cheddar stands out as Trader Joe’s celebrity cheese. With its crumbly texture and nutty notes, it resembles a blend of sharp cheddar and Parmesan. This cheese has garnered fan awards and earned a spot in TJ’s hall of fame lineup.

Use it creatively by cubing it for cheese boards, grating into mac and cheese, or shaving over salads. Its rich, complex taste elevates any dish.

Search for Unexpected Cheddar, and you’ll find it is a staple in many households.

2. Creamy Toscano Cheese Soaked in Syrah

Imagine a cheese that combines the rich creaminess of cheddar with the nutty essence of Parmesan, all enveloped in the elegance of Syrah wine. The purple rind adds a dramatic flair, while the inside remains firm and tangy.

Perfect for cheese boards when sliced and paired with figs, or grated into risotto. Pair it with almonds and dark chocolate for an indulgent snack.

This cheese is a staple in fancy cheese lineups for its bold flavor and affordable price.

3. Cheddar with Caramelized Onions

Cheddar with Caramelized Onions is a crowd favorite. This semi-soft cheese blends savory cheddar with sweet caramelized onions, creating a perfect harmony of flavors.

Ideal for melting into grilled cheese sandwiches or burgers, and a great addition to mac and cheese. Serve it with crusty bread on a cheese board for a delightful experience.

Its unique taste has earned it a cult following and frequent appearances in best-of lists.

4. Plain Goat Cheese Log (Chèvre)

Trader Joe’s plain goat cheese log is a staple for its tangy, creamy, and spreadable nature. It’s not only versatile but also budget-friendly, making it a customer favorite.

Crumbled over salads or roasted beets, it adds a delightful tang. Spread it on toast with honey, or stir into warm pasta with garlic for a creamy finish.

This cheese won the ‘favorite cheese’ award, showcasing its wide appeal.

5. Blueberry Vanilla Chèvre

For a dessert cheese experience, Blueberry Vanilla Chèvre is unmatched. Tangy goat cheese rolled in blueberry and vanilla offers a cheesecake-like delight.

Serve it with simple water crackers or fresh berries for a sweet treat. It also shines crumbled over a spinach and fruit salad.

This cheese is a fun, crowd-pleasing option, frequently highlighted by food bloggers.

6. Cranberry Chèvre

Cranberry Chèvre combines tangy goat cheese with sweet-tart cranberries, making it a festive favorite. While popular in fall and winter, it’s delightful year-round.

Pair it with nuts and cured meats on holiday boards or slice onto turkey sandwiches. It also enhances grain bowls with its vibrant flavor.

Editors frequently list it among their favorites for its unique taste.

7. Double Cream Brie

Mild, buttery, and charmingly approachable, Double Cream Brie is perfect for those who prefer gentle flavors. It’s a great choice for baking in puff pastry or serving on a cheese board.

Enjoy it at room temperature with sliced apples or pears. Melt it in grilled cheese with ham for a luxurious sandwich.

This brie is often highlighted for its versatility and creamy texture.

8. Manchego

Trader Joe’s Manchego brings the authentic taste of Spain to your table without the premium price. This firm, slightly salty cheese with a nutty flavor is a testament to quality.

Slice it with olives and Marcona almonds or shave over salads or roasted potatoes. Pair with quince paste for a classic Spanish delight.

Frequently praised, it’s a must-try for cheese lovers.

9. Double Cream Gouda

Rich and buttery, Double Cream Gouda is the ultimate crowd-pleaser. Its creamy, indulgent nature makes it perfect for melting into grilled cheese or casseroles.

Cube it for snack platters or pair it with beer or cider for a delightful experience. Its smooth texture is a favorite among nutritional experts.

This cheese is celebrated for its versatility and delicious consistency.

10. Italian Truffle Cheese

Transport your senses to an elegant wine bar with Italian Truffle Cheese. Semi-firm and infused with truffle, every bite is a luxurious delight.

Serve thin slices on crostini or shave over scrambled eggs. Pair with honey for an exquisite touch.

Highlighted as a must-try, this cheese adds sophistication to any board.

11. Baked Lemon Ricotta

Slightly sweet and lemony, Baked Lemon Ricotta is more than a cheese—it’s a dessert. Its cheesecake-like texture makes it a unique addition to dessert boards.

Spoon it onto graham crackers or serve with berries for a refreshing treat. Dollop on pancakes for a creative twist.

A quirky favorite, it’s often hailed as a hidden gem at Trader Joe’s.

12. Fromage Pavé (Seasonal)

Available seasonally, Fromage Pavé is a soft-ripened treasure. When it appears, fans stockpile this extra-creamy, brie-like cheese.

Let it reach full room temperature and serve with crusty bread. Melt it into a luxurious grilled cheese for a rich experience.

Described as ‘life-affirming,’ it’s a dramatic but fair testament to its quality.

13. Ciliegine Fresh Mozzarella

Small, cherry-sized balls of fresh mozzarella, Ciliegine are perfect for quick meals. Their meltability ensures pizzas and flatbreads aren’t flooded.

Use them in Caprese salad with cherry tomatoes and basil or dot over homemade pizza. Toss into warm pasta with olive oil for a delightful finish.

This cheese is a consistent favorite for its freshness and versatility.