15 Decadent Store-Bought Cherry Pies Worth A Try
Craving cherry pie without turning on the oven for hours? These store-bought favorites deliver that glossy, ruby filling and flaky crust you want, with zero stress.
From budget picks to bakery-counter beauties, you can serve a slice that feels homemade with a few easy upgrades. Let’s find your next go-to pie so dessert always feels special, even on a weeknight.
1. Costco Bakery Cherry Pie
This massive pie is built for gatherings, and it shows the moment you lift the lid. The filling leans generously tart-sweet, with big cherry pieces that hold their shape.
You get bakery energy without wrestling dough at home.
Warm a slice slightly so the juices loosen and perfume the room. Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and the contrast turns each bite plush and nostalgic.
You will appreciate how well it slices for such a hefty pie.
2. Sam’s Club Bakery Cherry Pie
Sam’s Club nails the party-sized pie sweet spot. The crust is sturdy enough for clean, chilled slices that look great on a dessert table.
The filling balances sweetness with a familiar cherry zing people expect.
Chill the pie before cutting so the wedges stay pristine. Serve with lightly sweetened whipped cream on the side to let folks customize richness.
This is a set-it-down-and-watch-it-disappear kind of dessert, perfect for potlucks and office celebrations without fuss.
3. Marie Callender’s Cherry Pie
Open the box and you can already imagine the classic holiday table. Bake until the crust turns deeply golden and the kitchen smells like butter and cherries.
The filling leans traditional, with a comfortable sweetness and gentle tart lift.
Let it rest so the juices set and slices hold. Add vanilla ice cream or a drizzle of warm cream.
When you want that old-school vibe without making dough, this brand delivers reliable comfort that resonates with guests.
4. Mrs. Smith’s Cherry Pie
Mrs. Smith’s is the pie you remember from simpler gatherings. It trends sweeter, so the cherries taste like a cheery summertime jam.
The crust is familiar and flaky, creating that fork-shattering first bite.
To brighten the sweetness, grate a little lemon zest over warm slices. The citrus perfume cuts through and makes the cherry pop.
This pie is dependable, budget friendly, and perfect when you want that bright diner-style sweetness in every bite.
5. Edwards Desserts Cherry Cream Pie
This pie leans decadent, creamy, and unapologetically dessert-first. Think silky, tangy cherry ribbons layered over plush cream in a crumbly cookie crust.
The texture is lush and spoonable, more mousse-like than traditional pastry.
Serve it straight from the fridge for clean, cool slices. Add extra whipped cream for drama, and let the cherry layer shine.
It feels like a dessert case treat you did not have to assemble, carrying that indulgent restaurant finish home without effort.
6. Sara Lee Cherry Pie
Sara Lee’s cherry pie is comfort in a box, ready when cravings hit. The cherry flavor is familiar and cozy, with a gentle tartness that keeps bites interesting.
The crust bakes to a reliable golden finish without babying it.
Warm a slice and top with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The temperature contrast softens the sweetness and turns everyday dessert into something special.
It is the dessert equivalent of a favorite sweater, always there when needed.
7. Village Inn Bakery-Style Cherry Pie
This grab-and-go option channels diner charm without the booth. The slices feel celebratory, with a bright, jammy cherry layer that reads like dessert, not a shortcut.
The crust has that pleasant shatter you want alongside coffee.
Serve at room temp for the best texture. Pair with a hot mug and let the cherries do the talking.
It scratches the nostalgic itch for a counter slice you can eat while chatting with friends or winding down a busy day.
8. Perkins Restaurant & Bakery Cherry Pie
Perkins brings that bakery-counter vibe home when you can find it. The slices are generous and satisfying, with a cherry profile that leans bright rather than candy-like.
Chilling keeps the structure neat and photogenic.
Top chilled wedges with whipped cream for a simple flourish. The contrast of cool cream and ruby filling is a winner.
It is the kind of pie you serve when you want dependable flavor and that classic restaurant comfort without leaving the neighborhood.
9. Publix Bakery Cherry Pie
Publix bakery pies give off bring-it-to-the-cookout energy. The crust bakes up flaky with a homey feel, and the filling hits that tart-sweet cherry lane.
It is a dependable choice that pleases a crowd without feeling heavy.
Warm slices slightly, then spoon a few extra cherries over the top if you have them. That simple upgrade makes it look bakery-fancy.
It travels well, serves neatly, and turns casual gatherings into something a little more celebratory without much effort.
10. Wegmans Bakery Cherry Pie
Wegmans often leans cleaner-tasting, with a crust that bites rather than crumbles. The cherries taste vivid, not syrupy, and the balance makes second slices inevitable.
It looks like something you picked up from a small-town bakery.
Chill it for tidy cuts, then finish each slice with a drizzle of warm cherry preserves. The extra shine and aroma make the flavors feel layered.
If you crave a better crust bite and a fresher cherry note, this one hits that mark.
11. Whole Foods Market Bakery Cherry Pie
This pie tends to taste like real ingredients first, sugar second. The cherries come through assertively, with a natural tartness that makes the filling feel lively.
The crust reads buttery and sturdy, giving nice definition to every forkful.
Serve at room temperature, crowned with lightly sweetened whipped cream. That subtle sweetness respects the fruit.
If you are sensitive to overly sweet pies, this feels balanced and modern, like a thoughtful bakery moment tucked into a weeknight dessert.
12. Trader Joe’s Cherry Pie or Tart-Style Dessert
Trader Joe’s rotates cherry desserts that keep things interesting. Whether it is a tart-style treat or a classic pie, expect buttery crust notes and a playful cherry profile.
It often feels like a creative spin rather than a copycat.
Serve warm with vanilla bean ice cream to amplify aroma and texture. Because availability changes, grab one when it appears.
It scratches the itch for something not boring, a little different, and still weeknight-friendly.
13. Kroger Bakery Cherry Pie
Kroger’s bakery pie is a solid value that punches above its price. The filling is pleasantly fruity, and the crust gives satisfying flakes without feeling greasy.
It is the dependable midweek dessert guests happily accept seconds of.
Warm a slice, add ice cream, then finish with a small pinch of salt. That trick sharpens the cherry flavor and makes the sweetness pop.
It is a tiny upgrade that turns a grocery pie into something memorable and craveable.
14. Walmart Bakery Cherry Pie
When you need dessert fast, Walmart’s cherry pie saves the day. The flavor is straightforward cherry comfort, and the crust bakes evenly for clean slices.
It is a wallet-friendly option that still delivers that ruby, glossy filling you crave.
Warm it gently and add ice cream or whipped cream to elevate things. A quick drizzle of store-bought cherry syrup also boosts shine.
This is the pie you can grab last minute and still feel proud serving to friends.
15. Target Grocery Cherry Pie Options
Target’s selection varies by location, but you can usually find a dependable cherry pie in the bakery or freezer case. The overall profile trends balanced, with approachable sweetness and a recognizable cherry bite.
It is the definition of convenient.
Warm slices and top with toasted almonds for texture. The crunch adds contrast and sophistication with almost no work.
If you are running errands and need a dessert that will please a crowd, this is an easy, successful grab.
