15 English Muffin Brands You Can Buy

If you love a crunchy toast with buttery nooks, this lineup is your shortcut to breakfast bliss. From bakery-soft classics to hearty sprouted grains, you will find a muffin that matches your morning mood. We will compare textures, toastability, and how well each one holds up to toppings. Get ready to pick your new go-to and level up every egg sandwich you build.

1. Thomas’

Thomas’ is the classic choice for a reason. The muffins toast evenly, delivering crisp edges and a tender interior with those signature nooks that hold butter beautifully. You get consistent results every time, which makes them perfect for busy mornings.

They handle jam, peanut butter, or egg and cheese without getting soggy. The flavor is pleasantly neutral, letting your toppings lead. If you want a dependable base that browns reliably and stays satisfying, Thomas’ delivers.

2. Bays

Bays leans bakery-soft with a tender crumb that browns beautifully. You get a gentle chew rather than a craggy bite, which feels luxurious under butter and honey. They toast quickly and evenly, creating a light crisp shell that contrasts the pillowy interior.

Great for eggs Benedict when you want delicacy over heft. The flavor is slightly buttery, enhancing sweet or savory toppings. If you prefer a softer, refined profile without sacrificing toastability, Bays shines.

3. Pepperidge Farm

Pepperidge Farm brings a slightly more bread-like bite. The structure is sturdy enough for heavy toppings like avocado, bacon, or a thick tomato slice. Toasting yields a satisfying crunch while keeping the interior resilient and chewy.

These are handy when you want reliability under saucy ingredients. The flavor leans mild and wholesome, making it a flexible everyday pick. If your breakfast stack tends to be loaded, expect these muffins to keep everything together without collapsing.

4. Trader Joe’s

Trader Joe’s offers a solid everyday muffin with a balanced chew and soft crumb. They toast evenly and quickly, delivering a crisp exterior and a warm interior that takes butter well. The flavor is straightforward, making them easy to pair with sweet or savory toppings.

They are a dependable fridge staple for busy weekdays. Use them for quick breakfast sandwiches, or dress them up with smoked salmon and cream cheese. If you want convenience and value with good texture, these deliver.

5. Whole Foods Market 365

Whole Foods Market 365 keeps things simple and dependable. These muffins toast to a clean crunch and have a neutral flavor that plays nicely with bold fillings. The texture holds up well for breakfast sandwiches without feeling dense.

They are a no-fuss choice for weekly meal prep. Slide in eggs, cheese, or sausage and the muffin stays intact. If you want straightforward quality at a fair price, 365 English muffins do the job.

6. Dave’s Killer Bread

Dave’s Killer Bread muffins lean hearty with whole grains and a robust chew. They feel substantial, making them ideal when you want staying power through the morning. Toasting brings out nuttiness and a deep, satisfying crunch.

They pair well with savory spreads, nut butters, and protein-packed fillings. Expect more flavor and a slightly denser bite than classic white muffins. If you want a healthier vibe without sacrificing taste, these are a go-to.

7. Ezekiel 4:9

Ezekiel 4:9 brings a sprouted-grain profile with an earthy, savory flavor. The muffins are firmer, toasting up crisp and holding structure under hearty toppings. You will notice a wholesome grain character that tastes nutritious and satisfying.

They shine with avocado, tomatoes, and salt, or a smear of hummus. The denser texture makes them great for open-faced breakfasts. If you like sprouted breads and robust crunch, these muffins belong in your rotation.

8. Oroweat

Oroweat is a reliable grocery-store staple with a softer, mild profile. They toast to a gentle crisp without getting too dry, which helps preserve a comfortable crumb. The flavor is easygoing and pairs well with butter and jam.

These muffins are great for households that prefer softness over rugged texture. They also make simple egg sandwiches that even picky eaters enjoy. For dependable, mellow muffins you can find almost anywhere, Oroweat fits nicely.

9. Nature’s Own

Nature’s Own offers an easygoing, classic taste with a gentle crumb. They toast evenly and quickly, building a light crunch that suits butter, jam, or honey. The texture is soft enough for kids yet sturdy enough for simple sandwiches.

Keep a pack handy for weekday breakfasts when you want zero fuss. The flavor stays neutral, letting toppings stand out. If your goal is consistent, family-friendly muffins at a good price, these deliver well.

10. Sara Lee

Sara Lee is soft and mild with a quick toast, perfect for easy mornings. The crumb stays tender while the exterior crisps just enough. Their balanced sweetness works beautifully with butter or fruit preserves.

When you need a weeknight breakfast that feels effortless, these muffins hit the spot. They also pair nicely with scrambled eggs for a simple sandwich. If you want comfort and convenience in one bag, Sara Lee is a smart pick.

11. Arnold

Arnold muffins tend to be sturdier, built to handle hefty fillings. Toasting brings a robust crunch and a satisfying chew that resists collapse. You can stack eggs, cheese, and sausage without fear of sogginess.

The flavor is balanced and slightly wheaty, making savory toppings shine. They are ideal for big breakfast sandwiches or meal-prepped freezer stacks. If durability and structure matter most, Arnold is a dependable option.

12. Lender’s

Lender’s is a familiar name that is easy to spot. Expect approachable muffins available in classic and whole wheat options. They toast reliably with a basic crunch and a simple flavor that works with everyday toppings.

Great for households where everyone wants something slightly different. The texture holds up to spreads without getting gummy. If you want straightforward, budget-conscious muffins that get the job done, Lender’s fits well.

13. Wegmans (store brand)

Wegmans’ store brand has a reputation for quality and consistency. These muffins toast evenly with a balanced crumb that works great for breakfast sandwiches. The flavor is clean and lightly wheaty, letting fillings take center stage.

If you shop Wegmans, this is an easy grab that rarely disappoints. They manage a nice contrast of crunch outside and softness within. For dependable results at a fair price, Wegmans is a strong pick.

14. Signature Select (store brand)

Signature Select delivers a budget-friendly, serviceable muffin. You get decent toastability and a mild flavor that suits everyday breakfasts. The texture is soft with enough structure to handle basic spreads or a quick egg and cheese.

These are perfect when you want value without sacrificing breakfast plans. Not fancy, but reliably tasty and convenient for families. If your supermarket carries Signature Select, it is a sensible, wallet-friendly choice.

15. Great Value (store brand)

Great Value lives up to its name with simple, affordable English muffins. They toast fast, offering a lightly crisp bite and soft center that welcomes butter and jam. The flavor is plain in a good way, making them versatile for crowds.

Excellent for stocking up when you have guests or meal prepping breakfast sandwiches. The structure holds well enough for basic fillings. If you want dependable, low-cost muffins you can find easily, Great Value performs.