17 Best Store-Bought Mayonnaise Brands To Keep On Hand
Mayonnaise can quietly upgrade everything from a turkey sandwich to a picnic potato salad. The right jar tastes rich and balanced, blends smoothly, and never feels heavy or weirdly sweet.
Whether you want classic comfort, tangy personality, or cleaner oils, there is a mayo that fits your vibe. Here are 17 dependable picks worth keeping in the fridge.
1. Duke’s Mayonnaise
Duke’s brings bold tang and a savory edge that makes sandwiches pop without overpowering fillings. The texture is thick yet spreadable, clinging beautifully to toasted bread and crisp lettuce.
You will notice less sweetness and more backbone, which helps balance rich meats.
It shines in potato salad, pimento cheese, and Southern-style slaws where acidity matters. Stir it into deviled eggs for extra depth, or whisk with hot sauce for a quick dip.
If you crave personality, this jar delivers consistent flavor and emulsifies sauces like a pro.
2. Hellmann’s
Hellmann’s is the definition of balanced mayo, with creamy texture, gentle tang, and just enough salt. It disappears into dressings while still bringing body, so salads taste richer without feeling greasy.
Spread it on bread, and everything just tastes more put together.
It is a reliable base for ranch, aioli, and coleslaw dressing, and it mixes smoothly with mustard or hot sauce. Families love the crowd-pleasing flavor, and it keeps consistency across regions.
When you want classic versatility, this is the jar that simply works.
3. Best Foods
Best Foods mirrors the classic profile many grew up with out West: creamy, stable, and lightly tangy. It is dependable for tuna salad and chicken salad because it binds without watering down texture.
The flavor stays neutral, so herbs and spices stand out.
This brand emulsifies dressings quickly and makes an effortless base for chipotle mayo or honey mustard. It is easy to recommend for everyday sandwiches and big-batch sides.
If you want predictable results for potlucks and lunches, Best Foods delivers consistency, body, and a clean finish every time.
4. Kewpie
Kewpie is richer and silkier, with a savory umami note that makes egg salad sing. The squeeze bottle helps you drizzle neat lines over rice bowls, sushi-style snacks, or okonomiyaki.
Expect a deeper egg flavor and softer acidity that feels luxurious on the palate.
It blends seamlessly into spicy mayo with sriracha, or into sesame dressings for crunchy slaws. Use it when you want lush texture without heaviness.
For those who crave a gourmet twist with minimal effort, Kewpie turns simple ingredients into restaurant-level bites you will crave often.
5. Blue Plate
Blue Plate brings a creamy, comforting Southern style that feels right at home in classic potluck dishes. The mouthfeel is smooth and slightly lighter than some, making it great for slaws.
There is gentle tang that keeps rich salads from tasting flat or overly fatty.
Use it in pimento cheese, chicken salad, or tomato sandwiches when you want nostalgic flavor. It spreads easily and blends well with relish, mustard, and paprika.
If you cook southern staples or host picnics, Blue Plate stays reliable, friendly, and delightfully scoopable for everyday cooking.
6. Sir Kensington’s
Sir Kensington’s leans gourmet, with a slightly brighter acidity and a clean finish that flatters aiolis. It feels crafted, not cloying, and your herb mixes will taste fresher.
The texture is creamy yet not gloopy, which helps spoon neatly onto fancy sandwich builds.
It plays well with roasted garlic, lemon, and olive oil, turning into restaurant-like spreads in seconds. Use it for elevated burgers or seared fish sandwiches.
When you want a pantry staple that dresses up easily, Sir Kensington’s offers dependable structure and nuanced flavor without overshadowing your ingredients.
7. Chosen Foods
Chosen Foods uses avocado oil for a cleaner, smoother taste that avoids heavy aftertaste. It is great when you prefer lighter-feeling dressings and dips but still want creamy texture.
The flavor stays neutral enough to mix with herbs and spices without fighting them.
Whisk it with lime and cilantro for taco slaw, or blend with chipotle for grain bowls. It handles meal prep well, staying stable in the fridge.
If avocado oil is your preference, this jar provides reliable emulsification, a silky finish, and an easy upgrade for everyday healthy-ish cooking.
8. Primal Kitchen
Primal Kitchen keeps ingredients simple while delivering a thick, satisfying texture. Expect a mild avocado oil character with a balanced tang that does not overwhelm.
It is a favorite for dressings, dips, and spreads when you want labels you can feel good about.
Use it in ranch, Caesar-style dressings, or as a base for dill and chive dips. It stays consistent and does not split easily.
If you cook for guests with varying preferences, this mayo brings clean flavor, creamy structure, and dependable versatility for weeknights, meal prep, and weekend gatherings.
9. Kraft
Kraft is mild, familiar, and perfect when you need something everyone will eat without debate. The texture is creamy and spreadable, making it ideal for big-batch tuna or chicken salad.
Its gentle sweetness and soft tang keep flavors approachable for kids and adults.
It blends smoothly into dips and party salads without turning them heavy. Add mustard, relish, or herbs, and it takes seasoning well.
For family meals and potlucks, Kraft is a trustworthy, friendly option that gets the job done and keeps sandwiches moist and balanced every single time.
10. Miracle Whip
Miracle Whip is not traditional mayo, but it earns its spot with sweet tang and zip. It delivers a lively flavor that some sandwiches absolutely need, especially nostalgic favorites.
The texture is creamy but lighter, which can perk up deli meats and crunchy lettuce.
Use it when you want extra sparkle in coleslaw or a zesty spread for cold cut subs. It is polarizing, sure, yet undeniably perfect for certain recipes.
Keep a jar on hand if those childhood flavors still call your name or you want contrast in richer fillings.
11. McCormick
McCormick offers a reliable, smooth mayo with a slightly lighter feel that still holds salads together. The flavor is balanced and unobtrusive, letting spices and crunchy add-ins take the spotlight.
It spreads easily without greasiness and stays creamy after mixing.
Use it in macaroni salad, deviled eggs, or a simple sandwich spread. It is a great everyday pick when you want predictability and a fair price.
If you care about consistent texture across batches, McCormick delivers dependable emulsification and friendly flavor that supports rather than dominates your recipes.
12. Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s mayo usually tastes fresh and clean, making it a solid value pick for daily cooking. The texture blends easily into dressings and spreads without separating.
You get a balanced profile that cooperates with herbs, pickles, and mustard.
It is great for stocking the fridge when you go through mayo steadily. Use it for aioli shortcuts, chicken salad, or a quick grilled corn dressing.
Shoppers appreciate the price-to-quality ratio and the way it plays well with bold or delicate flavors. It is a dependable everyday companion.
13. 365 by Whole Foods Market
365 by Whole Foods Market delivers a straightforward, workable mayo that mixes smoothly into dressings. The flavor is balanced, neither too sweet nor too tangy, which keeps it versatile.
It spreads nicely on sandwiches and complements fresh vegetables without masking them.
Use it as a base for herby spreads, simple aioli, or potato salad for weeknight dinners. The consistency holds up in the fridge, so leftovers stay creamy.
If you want a store-brand option that punches above its price, this jar offers dependable performance, clean taste, and easy compatibility with your favorite seasonings.
14. Great Value
Great Value keeps costs low while delivering a perfectly usable everyday mayo. The flavor is mild and cooperative, ideal when the mayo disappears into a recipe.
It spreads smoothly and blends well with relishes, spices, or hot sauce.
Use it for casseroles, tuna salad, or party salads where other flavors lead. It is a practical option for large families or frequent cooks who need volume.
If you prioritize budget but still want creamy texture, this store brand performs consistently and makes weeknight cooking easier without sacrificing the essentials.
15. Kirkland Signature
Kirkland Signature offers big-jar practicality with a clean, classic taste that suits many recipes. The texture is creamy and stable, ideal for frequent sandwich makers and dip lovers.
It keeps flavor balanced so add-ins like garlic, herbs, and pickles shine.
Perfect for large gatherings, tailgates, or meal prep weeks when you go through mayo fast. It does not dominate, which makes it a solid base for sauces.
If you want value and consistency without tradeoffs, this jar delivers quality and volume so you are never short during busy cooking stretches.
16. Publix (store-brand mayo)
Publix mayo is creamy, reliable, and earns loyalty for tasting good enough to be your main jar. The texture spreads easily and holds salads together without turning gloopy.
Flavor stays balanced, so it works for everything from BLTs to chicken salad.
It shines as a mix-in for quick dressings with lemon, pepper, and herbs. The value is strong for the quality you get.
If you shop Publix, this store brand makes stocking the fridge simple, keeping sandwiches juicy and picnic classics pleasantly creamy every time.
17. Hampton Creek
Hampton Creek offers an egg-free, plant-based spread that still feels mayo-like in sandwiches and sauces. The texture is creamy with a clean finish, great for mixed-diet households.
You get a gentle tang that complements veggies, roasted potatoes, and grain bowls.
Use it for vegan aioli, chickpea salad sandwiches, or creamy slaws that everyone can enjoy. It blends well with mustard, garlic, and lemon without splitting.
If you want an inclusive option that keeps flavor satisfying and texture stable, Hampton Creek is a smart pick for everyday plant-forward cooking and hosting.
