18 Gourmet Mac And Cheese Spots In New York City

New York City is a haven for food lovers, especially those with a penchant for comfort food like mac and cheese. Here are 18 must-visit spots across the city where this classic dish is elevated to gourmet levels.

1. S’MAC (East Village)

S’MAC, short for Sarita’s Macaroni & Cheese, is a dedicated mac-and-cheese heaven in the East Village. This place offers a dizzying array of styles and mix-ins, making each visit a new adventure. Whether you’re craving something classic or unique, S’MAC delivers with zero judgment.

The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it a perfect spot for mac lovers of all ages. Choose from pre-designed options or create your own masterpiece. From spicy jalapeños to smoky bacon, your culinary creativity is the only limit.

Great for groups or solo indulgence, S’MAC is a mac fan’s paradise.

2. Murray’s Cheese Bar (West Village)

Murray’s Cheese Bar in the West Village is where cheese dreams come to life. Known for its unapologetically rich dishes, their mac and cheese is no exception. It boasts a deep, grown-up flavor that comforts like a warm blanket.

The intimate setting makes it perfect for a casual date or a relaxed meal with friends. Expect a sophisticated cheese blend that satisfies even the most discerning palate. Pair it with a glass of wine for the full experience.

Murray’s has mastered the art of cheese, and their mac is a testament to their expertise.

3. Beecher’s Handmade Cheese (Flatiron)

Beecher’s Handmade Cheese in Flatiron is the place to go for mac and cheese purists. Known for its artisanal cheese, Beecher’s offers a classic version that’s creamy, cheesy, and utterly satisfying.

The rustic, open setting lets you watch cheese being made, adding to the experience. This is the ideal spot for those who appreciate quality ingredients and a straightforward approach.

Perfect for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, Beecher’s mac is dangerously easy to devour. It’s the classic done perfectly, and you’ll keep coming back for more.

4. Jacob’s Pickles (Upper West Side)

Nestled in the Upper West Side, Jacob’s Pickles is comfort food central. Their mac and cheese fits right into the vibe: expect big portions and big flavors that satisfy any craving.

The Southern-inspired setting makes it feel like a warm hug, perfect for rainy days or casual meet-ups. Enjoy the mac alongside their famous biscuits for a truly indulgent experience.

Known for its hearty offerings, Jacob’s Pickles delivers a meal that leaves you wanting a nap afterward. It’s a must-visit for comfort food aficionados.

5. Parm (Multiple locations)

Parm offers Italian-American comfort with a touch of elegance. With several locations across NYC, it’s a reliable spot when you want indulgent mac that still feels upscale.

Their mac and cheese, creamy and polished, pairs perfectly with classic Italian dishes. The vibrant atmosphere and attentive service make it an ideal choice for both family dinners and date nights.

Whether you’re in the mood for something familiar or adventurous, Parm’s menu has something to satisfy every palate. A true gem in the city’s culinary scene.

6. The Smith (Multiple locations)

The Smith, a dependable crowd-pleaser, offers mac and cheese that often steals the spotlight. With multiple locations throughout NYC, this trendy spot is a favorite for groups and gatherings.

The bustling atmosphere is energized by urban decor and lively chatter. Enjoy the mac as a side that quickly becomes the main event once it hits your table.

The Smith’s approach is all about comfort with a modern twist, making it an excellent choice for any occasion. Its mac and cheese is consistently delicious and satisfying.

7. Momofuku Noodle Bar (East Village and more)

While not exclusively a mac and cheese spot, Momofuku Noodle Bar is known for rich, comforting dishes with a chef-driven twist. Located in the East Village and other areas, it offers a slightly different take on this classic comfort dish.

The innovative culinary approach ensures that every bite is memorable, making it worth a try for those seeking something unique. Here, traditional flavors meet modern creativity.

Momofuku’s lively ambiance and culinary flair make it a standout choice for adventurous eaters. It’s a place where mac and cheese becomes a culinary journey.

8. Junior’s (Downtown Brooklyn, Times Square)

Known primarily for its legendary cheesecake, Junior’s also excels at comfort food like mac and cheese. With locations in Downtown Brooklyn and Times Square, it’s a beloved spot for hearty, classic dishes.

The mac and cheese here is as satisfying as their desserts, offering a rich and filling experience that pairs well with other old-school favorites. It’s the perfect choice for a comforting meal.

Junior’s combines nostalgia with quality, creating an inviting atmosphere for both locals and tourists. A true New York institution, it never disappoints.

9. Del Frisco’s Grille (Multiple locations)

For those who enjoy their mac on the steakhouse side, Del Frisco’s Grille offers the perfect option. With locations throughout the city, this upscale spot serves mac and cheese that’s rich and meant to be shared.

The elegant setting and attentive service enhance the dining experience, making it suitable for special occasions or a night out. Expect a dish that’s heavier and deeply satisfying.

Del Frisco’s mac and cheese is all about indulgence, and it’s an essential side for steak lovers. A classic choice for a luxurious meal.

10. Quality Meats (Midtown West)

Quality Meats in Midtown West is where mac and cheese meets luxury. As a steakhouse-adjacent establishment, it offers a side dish that refuses to be overshadowed.

The elegant decor and sophisticated atmosphere create a dining experience that’s both refined and inviting. The mac, rich and creamy, is crafted to complement their high-quality meats.

It’s the kind of place where every dish feels like a special occasion, and their mac and cheese is no exception. A must-try for those seeking culinary indulgence.

11. Blue Smoke (Manhattan)

Blue Smoke in Manhattan brings BBQ and mac together in perfect harmony. Known for its smoky, savory dishes, this spot delivers mac and cheese that feels like it was made for meat lovers.

The laid-back, rustic setting makes it ideal for casual get-togethers with friends or family. Enjoy the mac alongside their famous ribs for an unforgettable meal.

Blue Smoke’s approach is all about bold flavors and hearty portions, making it a strong contender for your BBQ cravings. A delightful spot for comfort food enthusiasts.

12. Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque (Multiple locations)

Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque offers a casual setting where mac and cheese is a natural fit. With multiple locations, it’s a go-to spot for quick, satisfying meals.

The lively atmosphere and friendly service make it an appealing choice for both lunch and dinner. The mac here complements their BBQ offerings perfectly, providing creamy comfort with every bite.

Whether you’re in a hurry or looking to relax, Mighty Quinn’s delivers on taste and convenience. It’s a reliable choice for barbecue and mac enthusiasts alike.

13. Clinton St. Baking Company (Lower East Side)

Clinton St. Baking Company on the Lower East Side is famous for its brunch, but don’t overlook their mac and cheese. This cozy spot offers a creamy, delightful version that pairs well with their pancakes.

The homey vibe and welcoming staff create a comforting atmosphere, making it a popular choice for locals. Adding mac to your brunch table is rarely a bad decision.

Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Clinton St. Baking provides a memorable dining experience. It’s a beloved spot for comfort food lovers.

14. Friedman’s (Multiple locations)

Friedman’s is a cozy dining spot known for all-day comfort food. With multiple locations, it’s a favorite for those seeking a relaxed meal with familiar flavors.

Their mac and cheese, a steady favorite, is perfect for any time of day. The inviting environment makes it a great place to unwind and enjoy hearty dishes.

Friedman’s offers a menu filled with comforting classics, and their mac is a standout. It’s the kind of place where you feel at home, no matter how busy the city gets.

15. Hill Country Barbecue Market (Flatiron area)

Located in the Flatiron area, Hill Country Barbecue Market brings Texas-style BBQ to NYC. Mac and cheese is a natural fit here, offering creamy comfort alongside smoky brisket.

The lively, rustic setting creates an authentic experience where food is celebrated and enjoyed. It’s the place to be for hearty meals that satisfy every craving.

Known for its bold flavors and generous portions, Hill Country is a must-visit for BBQ enthusiasts. It’s the “give me brisket and a creamy side” choice that never disappoints.

16. Sweet Chick (Multiple locations)

Sweet Chick, with locations across NYC, offers comfort food with flair. Known for its chicken and waffles, the mac and cheese here is a natural companion to anything crispy and fried.

The vibrant, eclectic setting makes every visit enjoyable, and the friendly service adds to the experience. Perfect for brunch or dinner, Sweet Chick’s mac is a crowd-pleaser.

Whether you’re indulging in comfort or exploring new flavors, Sweet Chick delivers. It’s a trendy spot that captures the city’s culinary diversity.

17. Milk Bar (Multiple locations)

Milk Bar isn’t your traditional mac and cheese spot, but it’s a fun stop on a comfort-food journey. Known for its quirky, over-the-top desserts, this spot adds balance with its sweet offerings.

Located in various parts of NYC, Milk Bar’s whimsical atmosphere is perfect for those with a sweet tooth. Pairing savory with sweet here creates a unique dining experience.

It’s a playful choice for food explorers looking to mix things up. Milk Bar’s inventive approach keeps the city’s food scene exciting and delicious.

18. Eataly (Flatiron, Downtown)

Eataly is a playground for lovers of Italian cuisine. Located in Flatiron and Downtown, it’s an expansive space where mac-ish baked pasta fulfills cheesy cravings.

The bustling marketplace atmosphere makes wandering a pleasure as you discover dishes that melt your willpower. From classic pasta to creative twists, Eataly offers something for every palate.

Ideal for foodies looking to explore, Eataly brings Italy’s culinary richness to NYC. It’s a delightful journey through flavors, textures, and aromas that captivate the senses.