20 New York Bagel Shops Locals Claim Serve The Best In The City
New York City is renowned for its bagels, a staple that locals and visitors alike crave. With countless options across the boroughs, finding the perfect bagel spot can be a delicious adventure. Here’s a curated list of 20 bagel shops that New Yorkers insist are serving the best in town.
1. Ess-a-Bagel
Ess-a-Bagel, nestled in Midtown East, is a beloved institution where bagel enthusiasts gather for a hearty, chew-filled experience. These bagels are known for their substantial size and satisfying texture, making them a favorite among locals.
The shop exudes an old-school charm, where the aroma of freshly baked bagels fills the air. Customers often enjoy customizing their bagels with a variety of cream cheeses and smoked fish.
Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Ess-a-Bagel promises a quintessential New York bagel experience that feels both nostalgic and fulfilling.
2. Absolute Bagels
On the Upper West Side, Absolute Bagels is a beloved neighborhood gem known for its perfect balance of chewiness and crust. The shop offers a welcoming atmosphere where patrons are greeted with warm smiles and the inviting smell of freshly baked bagels.
Locals flock here, often forming lines that attest to the shop’s popularity and quality. Each bagel is crafted with care, ensuring a consistently delightful bite.
Regulars appreciate the simplicity and quality, making Absolute Bagels a staple for both morning routines and leisurely weekend brunches.
3. Tompkins Square Bagels
Located in the eclectic East Village, Tompkins Square Bagels is known for its creativity and flair. The shop offers unique cream cheese flavors that add a fun twist to the traditional bagel experience.
It’s a place where both classic and adventurous palates find joy, whether it’s a straightforward poppy seed bagel or one adorned with inventive spreads. The decor reflects the vibrant neighborhood it resides in, adding to the overall lively atmosphere.
Tompkins Square Bagels is a must-visit for anyone seeking something beyond the ordinary in their bagel journey.
4. Murray’s Bagels
In the heart of Greenwich Village, Murray’s Bagels stands as a beacon for traditional bagel lovers. Here, patrons find a straightforward approach to bagels, celebrating the simplicity of quality ingredients and expert craftsmanship.
The shop’s no-toasting policy ensures each bagel retains its perfect texture, offering an authentic experience. The menu includes a variety of spreads, each complementing the bagels without overpowering them.
Regulars appreciate the consistency and warmth of Murray’s, making it a go-to spot for both quick bites and leisurely breakfasts.
5. H&H Bagels
H&H Bagels, located on the Upper West Side, is a name synonymous with New York bagels. Known for their fresh, hot-from-the-oven offerings, H&H Bagels draws both locals and tourists alike.
The shop’s bagels are celebrated for their lightness and flavor, making them an irresistible choice for many. With a history dating back to the 1970s, this establishment has become an iconic part of New York’s culinary landscape.
For anyone seeking an authentic slice of New York bagel history, H&H Bagels is a must-visit destination.
6. Pick A Bagel
Pick A Bagel, with multiple locations across Manhattan, offers a wide array of options for bagel enthusiasts. Known for its versatility, the shop caters to both traditionalists and those seeking variety in their daily bagel fix.
The bustling atmosphere reflects the city’s vibrancy, making it a popular stop for busy New Yorkers on the go. Customers appreciate the abundance of choices, from classic bagels to more adventurous combinations.
Whether it’s a quick breakfast or a leisurely lunch, Pick A Bagel delivers a satisfying experience that resonates with the city’s diverse palate.
7. Zucker’s Bagels & Smoked Fish
Zucker’s Bagels & Smoked Fish offers an appetizing-shop experience that celebrates the classic New York bagel and lox tradition. With locations throughout Manhattan, Zucker’s is known for its strong bagel quality and the freshest smoked fish.
The shop embodies a deli-style vibe, offering a full range of appetizing options to complement your bagel choice. Regulars enjoy the combination of chewy bagels with perfectly crafted toppings.
Zucker’s delivers a taste of New York history with every bite, making it a beloved spot for those who crave the classic bagel experience.
8. Leo’s Bagels
Leo’s Bagels, situated in the bustling Financial District, offers a classic bagel sandwich experience that feels distinctly New York. Known for their hearty and flavorful sandwiches, Leo’s attracts both office workers and tourists alike.
The shop’s cozy interior provides a welcoming respite from the busy city streets. Patrons often stop by for a quick lunch or a leisurely breakfast, enjoying the balance of fresh ingredients and expertly crafted bagels.
Leo’s Bagels is a staple for anyone seeking a satisfying meal that captures the essence of downtown New York.
9. Tal Bagels
Tal Bagels, located on the Upper East Side, is a neighborhood favorite for those craving straightforward, satisfying bagels. The shop offers a classic deli-style experience, complete with a range of spreads and toppings.
Locals appreciate the consistent quality and friendly service, making it a staple for both quick breakfasts and relaxed brunches. Each bagel is crafted with care, ensuring a flavorful and satisfying bite every time.
With its welcoming atmosphere, Tal Bagels continues to be a cherished stop in the Upper East Side bagel scene.
10. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys
Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys is a historic gem located in the Lower East Side, celebrated for its exceptional bialys and beloved bagels. Founded in 1936, Kossar’s is a testament to New York’s rich culinary heritage.
The shop’s vintage interior adds to its charm, attracting both locals and history enthusiasts. While bialys are the signature offering, the bagels hold their own, delivering a satisfying chew and flavor.
Kossar’s is a must-visit for those who appreciate the intersection of history and taste in their bagel experience.
11. Russ & Daughters
Russ & Daughters, a Lower East Side legend, offers a sublime bagel-and-fish experience that New Yorkers cherish. Known for its premium smoked fish and iconic bagels, this shop stands as a beacon of appetizing culture.
The vintage ambiance adds to the allure, drawing in both long-time patrons and curious newcomers. Each visit promises a taste of tradition, with expertly crafted sandwiches and spreads.
For anyone seeking the quintessential New York bagel experience, Russ & Daughters offers an unforgettable journey through taste and history.
12. Barney Greengrass
Barney Greengrass, affectionately known as ‘The Sturgeon King,’ is an Upper West Side institution with a rich history in New York deli culture. Established in 1908, this family-run shop is famed for its smoked fish and delightful bagels.
The atmosphere is steeped in tradition, with loyal patrons returning for their favorite bagel and fish combinations. The decor reflects its storied past, adding to the charm of each visit.
For those seeking a truly authentic New York deli experience, Barney Greengrass delivers with every delicious bite.
13. Utopia Bagels
Utopia Bagels in Whitestone, Queens, has earned a cult following for its thick, chewy bagels that satisfy even the most discerning palates. The shop’s lively atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a destination worth traveling for.
Each bagel is crafted with precision, offering a perfect balance of chewiness and flavor that customers adore. The modern vibe complements the timeless appeal of their products, creating a unique blend of the past and present.
For a truly memorable bagel experience, Utopia Bagels stands out as a must-visit spot in Queens.
14. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company
Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company, located in Astoria, Queens, is a beloved neighborhood spot that draws in crowds with its big, flavorful bagels. Loyal patrons often line up, a testament to the shop’s quality and popularity.
The community atmosphere is palpable, making it a perfect spot to relax with a bagel and a cup of coffee. The menu offers a wide range of options, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
With its strong local following and commitment to excellence, Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company remains a cherished part of the Astoria scene.
15. La Bagel Delight
La Bagel Delight, with multiple locations across Queens, is a staple for those seeking hearty bagels and satisfying sandwiches. Known for its robust offerings, the shop delivers on both quality and quantity.
The friendly neighborhood vibe creates a welcoming environment for regulars and newcomers alike. Each bagel is crafted to perfection, providing a delightful start to any day.
For a reliable and delicious bagel experience in Queens, La Bagel Delight consistently delivers satisfaction and smiles to its patrons.
16. Court Street Bagels
Court Street Bagels, located in the charming Carroll Gardens neighborhood of Brooklyn, offers a cozy escape for bagel lovers. Known for their delicious bagel sandwiches, the shop captures the essence of community and comfort.
The welcoming atmosphere invites patrons to linger, whether enjoying a quick bite or a leisurely meal. Each sandwich is carefully crafted, showcasing fresh ingredients and flavorful combinations.
A beloved spot among locals, Court Street Bagels provides a delightful taste of Brooklyn charm with every visit.
17. Bagel Hole
Bagel Hole, situated in Park Slope, Brooklyn, is celebrated for its smaller, denser bagels that pack a serious chew. This traditional shop offers a no-frills experience that appeals to bagel purists.
The rustic charm of the interior sets the stage for a straightforward yet satisfying bagel experience. Each bite reveals the shop’s dedication to quality and authenticity.
For those who appreciate a classic New York bagel with a hearty chew, Bagel Hole delivers an experience that feels both nostalgic and fulfilling.
18. Bergen Bagels
Bergen Bagels, with several locations in Brooklyn, offers dependable bagels that have become a weekly habit for many locals. The shop’s straightforward approach to bagels ensures quality and consistency.
Customers appreciate the no-drama vibe, making it a reliable choice for breakfast or brunch. Each location maintains the same dedication to excellent service and tasty offerings.
For those seeking a familiar and satisfying bagel experience in Brooklyn, Bergen Bagels stands as a steadfast favorite among residents.
19. Popup Bagels
Popup Bagels, a newer addition to Manhattan’s bagel scene, offers a fresh take with warm, tear-and-share style bagels. The shop’s modern approach appeals to those seeking something different from the traditional bagel.
The inviting, stylish interior provides a perfect backdrop for enjoying these unique creations. Each bagel is designed to be shared, enhancing the communal dining experience.
With its innovative style and expanding presence, Popup Bagels is quickly becoming a favorite for those exploring new bagel horizons in the city.
20. Hot Bagels & More
Hot Bagels & More, located in Kingsbridge, The Bronx, offers a genuine neighborhood bagel shop experience that residents adore. Known for their freshly baked bagels, the shop exudes a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
The friendly staff and local charm make it a popular choice among community members. Patrons enjoy the robust flavors and comforting textures that each bagel provides.
For a real taste of The Bronx’s bagel culture, Hot Bagels & More delivers an authentic and satisfying experience that keeps locals coming back for more.
