20 Top-Rated Jimmy John’s Sandwiches You Shouldn’t Overlook
Craving something fast, fresh, and wildly satisfying from Jimmy John’s, but not sure what to order next? This guide highlights fan favorites and sleeper hits that deliver big flavor without overcomplicating lunch. You will get quick tips to customize each pick so you can dial in the crunch, heat, and balance you love. Let’s find your new go-to sandwich and skip the menu guesswork.
1. #5 Vito (Italian Sub)
The Vito brings that classic Italian combo with salami, capicola, and provolone, all balanced by lettuce, tomato, onion, and the signature oregano-basil. Oil and vinegar tie everything together with a bright, tangy finish that never feels heavy. If you like deli counter nostalgia, this one hits the spot.
Want a little more charge without losing balance? Add hot peppers for kick and watch the flavors pop against the cool veggies. It is a great entry point into the Italian side of the menu, especially when you want bold without going overboard.
2. Spicy East Coast Italian
This is the Vito’s bolder cousin, stacked with double salami and capicola for a meaty, peppery punch. Hot peppers bring real heat while oil, vinegar, and oregano-basil keep things classic. The provolone melts into the mix, mellowing the spice just enough.
Ask for EZ mayo to keep the spice leading the charge without dulling the edges. If you want a big, headlining bite that wakes up your taste buds, this sandwich delivers. It is a power move for anyone who craves heat and heritage.
3. Italian Night Club
The Italian Night Club levels up the classic profile with a club build, meaning more meat and more everything. Expect a deeper savory profile with provolone smoothing each bite. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and the herb blend make it feel bright, not heavy.
Ask for extra oregano-basil if you love that old-school deli aroma. It turns the sandwich into a fragrant, nostalgic throwback with modern speed. Perfect when you want a fuller Italian without going full Gargantuan.
4. #2 Big John (Roast Beef)
Big John keeps it simple and satisfying with tender roast beef, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. The beef is the star, and the texture is soft without being mushy. It is a minimal effort pick that always lands.
For a classic deli upgrade, add provolone and onion. The cheese adds creaminess while onion brings that crisp snap. It is a dependable weekday lunch when you want no-fuss comfort.
5. Hunter’s Club (Roast Beef Club)
Hunter’s Club doubles the roast beef for a rich, meaty bite that still feels balanced. Provolone provides creamy support while the veggies keep it crisp. It is hearty without slipping into heavy territory.
Swap to wheat for a nuttier chew and add hot peppers for a lively finish. You will get layers of flavor that stay interesting from first bite to last. Ideal when you want beef with a little edge.
6. Billy Club (Roast Beef & Ham)
Billy Club mixes roast beef and ham for a savory, slightly smoky duet. Provolone ties them together while Dijon adds a sharp, zingy note. The result is balanced and lively, not just meat piled high.
If you like a clearer mustard bite, ask for extra Dijon. It brings the whole flavor map into focus. This one shines for folks who want contrast and a touch of deli drama.
7. #1 Pepe (Ham & Provolone)
The Pepe is the definition of simple done right. Ham and provolone deliver salty, creamy comfort while lettuce and tomato keep it fresh. Mayo rounds it out with a soft, familiar finish.
For crunch and snap, add pickle and onion. Those little tweaks wake up the ham without overpowering it. When you want easy, reliable, and fast, the Pepe is tough to beat.
8. #4 Turkey Tom (Turkey & Mayo)
Turkey Tom is clean and classic, perfect when you want a straightforward turkey sandwich. The turkey is lean yet flavorful, with mayo lending a smooth finish. Fresh veggies keep every bite crisp.
Add avocado spread and cucumber for extra coolness and texture. It feels lighter while still satisfying, especially on a busy day. A must for turkey loyalists who love simple upgrades.
9. Country Club (Turkey & Ham Club)
The Country Club brings turkey, ham, and provolone together for a crowd-pleasing balance. Nothing fights for attention, and every bite feels clean and steady. It is the kind of sandwich that pleases everyone in the group.
Swap oil and vinegar for heavy mayo to brighten things up. The acidity wakes the meats and adds deli-shop personality. A versatile pick when you need a safe, tasty bet.
10. Club Lulu (Turkey, Bacon & Lettuce)
Club Lulu blends lean turkey with smoky bacon for a crispy-salty duet. Lettuce keeps it crunchy while the build stays light enough for everyday eating. It is familiar, friendly, and fast.
Unwich this one if you want a lighter lunch without losing flavor. The bacon still shines and the turkey feels clean. Great for a midday boost that will not slow you down.
11. JJBLT
The JJBLT sticks to the classic formula of bacon, lettuce, and tomato, and it nails it. The bacon brings a smoky crunch that plays perfectly with cool veggies. Every bite feels nostalgic and satisfying.
Add avocado spread or a slice of cheese for a fuller, creamier bite. Those extras make it feel more like a meal without losing the BLT spirit. Simple pleasures, dialed in.
12. Beach Club (Turkey, Avocado & Cucumber)
Beach Club is breezy and cool with turkey, provolone, avocado, and cucumber. The textures are silky and crisp, with a herby lift from oregano-basil. It tastes like a picnic you can grab on the go.
Hit it with extra vinegar for sparkle and a tiny flavor snap. You will get refreshment and comfort in the same bite. Ideal for warm days or anytime you want something chill.
13. #3 Totally Tuna
Totally Tuna brings a classic tuna salad with celery and onion for crunch and a little kick. It is satisfying without feeling heavy, especially with cucumber and lettuce in the mix. The flavors taste homemade in the best way.
Order it on wheat or as an Unwich to keep things light and tidy. The texture stays creamy yet crisp. Great when you want comfort with a fresh finish.
14. Club Tuna
Club Tuna turns the tuna classic richer with provolone layered in. That cheese adds depth and a mild buttery note that plays well with the salad. The result is cozy but not dull.
Add hot peppers to cut through the creaminess and deliver a fun zing. It keeps bites lively from start to finish. A smart pick when you want tuna with a twist.
15. #6 The Veggie
The Veggie shines with provolone, avocado spread, and cucumber at the center. Lettuce and tomato add fresh crunch while the avocado brings silky heft. It is satisfying even if you usually go for meat.
Ask for extra avocado and oregano-basil to boost richness and herbiness. The seasoning brings it to life without needing more sauce. A reliable plant-forward choice that never feels like a compromise.
16. Jimmy Cubano
Jimmy Cubano channels pressed-sandwich vibes with bacon, smoked ham, provolone, Dijon, and pickles. The tangy mustard and briny pickles make each bite snap. It is layered, punchy, and seriously craveable.
Go for extra pickles and EZ mayo to keep it snappy without overpowering the Dijon. You get crunch, smoke, and tang in perfect rotation. A bold pick for flavor seekers.
17. Bootlegger Club (Roast Beef & Turkey)
The Bootlegger Club pairs lean turkey with savory roast beef for a balanced, meaty contrast. Provolone smooths things out while fresh veggies keep the bite lively. It is satisfying without tipping into heavy.
Add onion and hot peppers for zip and a little heat. The layers stay clean and distinct, so every bite feels composed. A great two-protein option when you want variety.
18. The Gargantuan
The Gargantuan is a full-on feast with all the Italian meats, turkey, roast beef, and provolone. It is big, bold, and built to share, though you can absolutely tackle it solo. Oil and vinegar keep the whole stack bright.
Split it and add extra oil and vinegar for balance across that massive build. Each bite lands with savory depth and herby perfume. Perfect for parties or serious hunger.
19. Slim 5 (Salami & Capicola)
Slim 5 is minimalist Italian done fast, with just salami and capicola on that signature bread. It is pure, meaty flavor without distractions. Perfect when you want to keep things tight and efficient.
Ask for oregano-basil and oil and vinegar to add classic deli character. Those condiments come at no extra charge and elevate the whole experience. A stealth favorite for quick cravings.
20. Little John #5 (Mini Italian)
Little John #5 gives you the Vito flavor set in a smaller, snackable format. You still get the Italian meats and provolone with the herby, tangy finish. Portion control never tasted so complete.
Add hot peppers to keep the flavor lively despite the smaller size. It is a great pick for kids or an afternoon bite. All the character, less commitment.
