22 Best Ben & Jerry’s Flavors
Some pints are comforts, others are full-on adventures, and Ben & Jerry’s nails both. You’ll find creamy bases, chunky swirls, and big mix-ins that turn every spoonful into a mini treasure hunt.
Whether you chase nostalgic cookie dough or bold coffee buzz, there’s a flavor waiting to be your new default. Let’s dig into the best so you can pick your next freezer MVP.
1. Half Baked
Half Baked feels like two favorites high-fiving in your bowl. You get rich chocolate and mellow vanilla hugging big brownie hunks and soft cookie dough nuggets.
Every scoop swings between gooey, cakey, and creamy satisfaction.
If you hate choosing, this is your peace treaty. The textures land perfectly, with dough that stays soft and brownies that taste fresh, not chalky.
It’s the spoonful that makes movie nights better, breakups gentler, and Tuesdays heroic.
2. Chocolate Fudge Brownie
This is straight-up chocolate therapy. The base is deep and cocoa-forward, not shy about the fudge.
Then those brownie pieces crash the party, tasting like actual brownies, not random crumbs.
Every bite brings chew and melt in the best balance. If your taste buds crave intensity, this pint delivers without getting cloying.
Keep a spoon nearby for late-night cravings, celebrations, or just when you want chocolate to do all the talking.
3. The Tonight Dough
The Tonight Dough is pure late-night chaos in the best way. Caramel and chocolate ice creams swirl around brownie bites and two kinds of cookie dough.
Every spoonful flips textures like a channel surfer.
There’s sweet-then-salty, chewy-then-creamy, and a hit of nostalgia. You keep digging for more mix-ins and somehow they keep showing up.
If indecision is your brand, this pint rewards curiosity with a new surprise in nearly every bite.
4. Americone Dream
Americone Dream nails the sweet-crunchy combo. The vanilla base is clean and creamy, leaving room for caramel ribbons to shine.
Then those fudge-covered waffle cone chunks show up big, staying crisp and snackable.
It tastes like walking past an ice cream stand on a summer night and deciding to treat yourself. Nothing feels overdone, just balanced nostalgia with extra crunch.
If “one more bite” is your catchphrase, this pint makes it inevitable.
5. Cherry Garcia
Cherry Garcia is iconic for a reason. The cherry base is fruity without tasting like candy, and the pieces of real cherries feel generous.
Chocolate chunks break up the sweetness with a smooth, slightly bitter snap.
It’s balanced, simple, and surprisingly elegant for a rock-and-roll pint. If you want flavor that never shouts but always satisfies, this is your steady pick.
Keep it for nights when you crave something familiar yet special.
6. Phish Food
Phish Food is playful and big-hearted. The chocolate base is lush, then marshmallow swirls stretch like gooey ribbons.
Caramel sneaks in with buttery sweetness, and those fish-shaped chocolates add crunch and charm.
It feels like a dessert jam session where everyone solos. Each spoonful hits creamy, sticky, and crunchy in rhythm.
If fun is your flavor compass, this pint points true north and keeps you dipping back for encore bites.
7. Chunky Monkey
Chunky Monkey turns banana skeptics into loyal fans. The banana base tastes like real fruit, not imitation.
Fudge chunks bring a dark chocolate pop, and walnuts add earthy crunch that sticks the landing.
There’s a cozy banana bread vibe without the oven. Every scoop is creamy, nutty, and just sweet enough.
If you want character over basic vanilla, this pint has personality for days and a texture you can actually chew.
8. Peanut Butter Cup
This is peanut butter turned up to eleven. The base is thick and salty-sweet, like a frozen spoonful from the jar.
Big peanut butter cup pieces show off creamy centers and chocolatey shells.
It’s rich, indulgent, and extremely hard to portion. You’ll promise yourself a few bites, then find the bottom.
For PB purists, it’s the gold standard that never feels gimmicky, just deeply satisfying in every scoop.
9. Peanut Butter Half Baked
If team PB owns your heart, this spin on Half Baked is the move. You still get brownie hunks and dough bites, but the peanut butter note leads.
It’s salty, sweet, and extra creamy.
The mix-ins hit familiar comfort while the PB base adds a bold twist. Expect that same can’t-stop scooping feeling with more nutty depth.
Great for when you want decadence that leans savory-sweet rather than purely sugary.
10. Milk & Cookies
Milk & Cookies tastes like dunking cookies until they turn perfectly soggy, then sipping the leftover milk. The base has that cereal-bowl finish, gentle and comforting.
Cookie swirls and chunks add crunchy contrast and real chocolate hits.
It feels cozy, like late-night kitchen lights and a quiet house. If you love cookies-and-milk energy, this pint bottles it.
Not too loud, not too plain, just exactly right for snacking.
11. Cookies and Cream Cheesecake
This pint doubles down on dessert. You get creamy cheesecake vibes with a tang that keeps things lively.
Cookies-and-cream crunch adds texture and classic chocolate cookie flavor.
It’s a dessert-on-dessert situation that still feels balanced. The tangy base keeps sweetness from steamrolling your taste buds.
If you crave cheesecake but want spoonable convenience, this one delivers with satisfying bite and creamy finish.
12. Mint Chocolate Cookie
Mint Chocolate Cookie goes hard on cookie content. The mint is fresh and cool without toothpaste territory.
Big cookie chunks bring cocoa richness and that satisfying crumble-snap.
If you like mint’s clean finish with serious texture, this pint nails it. The balance keeps you refreshed while still feeling dessert-level indulgent.
Perfect for after-dinner spoons and hot-day cravings.
13. Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch
This one mixes dessert with coffee shop vibes. The coffee base is smooth and robust, not bitter.
Toffee bits add buttery snap, while chocolate pieces round out the richness.
Every bite lands like a sweet latte with a crunchy topping. It satisfies caffeine cravings without needing a shot of espresso.
Great for afternoon pick-me-ups or as your late-night study buddy.
14. Coffee Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz
If you want coffee that actually tastes like coffee, this pint brings it. The flavor is bold and roasty, with a confidence that stands up to sweet mix-ins.
Chocolate espresso chips add crunch and echo that cafe vibe.
You’ll feel awake, satisfied, and a little proud of your good taste. It’s ideal when you want dessert that doesn’t fade into the background.
Strong, smooth, and seriously craveable.
15. Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake
Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake is unapologetically rich. The cheesecake base brings tang and creaminess, while caramel swirls ribbon through like buttery gold.
Chocolate bits add contrast so it never feels one-note.
It’s a luxe spoonful, perfect for when you want the dessert cart without leaving home. Pace yourself or don’t.
Either way, you’ll be happy.
16. Chocolate Therapy
Chocolate Therapy is the comfort blanket of pints. The chocolate flavor is layered, like cocoa, fudge, and pudding all teamed up.
It’s smooth, deeply satisfying, and absolutely devoted to chocolate lovers.
When the day went sideways, this is the spoon you trust. It melts into a calm, rich finish that doesn’t overwhelm.
Pair with a quiet playlist and give yourself a minute.
17. New York Super Fudge Chunk
This is the definition of a loaded pint. The chocolate base is rich, then the avalanche starts: white chocolate chunks, dark chocolate pieces, almonds, and walnuts.
Every scoop is a texture parade.
If you like your ice cream busy, this one never gives a dull bite. It’s big, classic, and built for sharing or hoarding.
Your call. Expect chocolate overload with a satisfying nutty crunch in every spoonful.
18. Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake balances fruity brightness with creamy tang. The strawberry ribbons taste like real berries, not syrup.
Graham-style crumbs bring that bakery crust note you crave.
It feels like a slice of cheesecake turned spoonable. Sweet, tart, and a little crunchy where it counts.
If you want fruit without losing decadence, you’ve met your match.
19. Cinnamon Buns
This pint tastes like walking into a warm bakery. The cinnamon base is comforting, and the brown sugar swirl adds sticky bun sweetness.
Pastry chunks make it feel like breakfast went dessert mode.
It’s nostalgic and indulgent without going overboard. Perfect for chilly nights or when you want a cinnamon roll without preheating anything.
Just grab a spoon and let the cozy roll in.
20. Salted Caramel Brownie
Salted Caramel Brownie brings the sweet-salty magic. The caramel base is buttery and smooth, while the salt sharpens every bite.
Brownie pieces add fudgy heft so it finishes strong.
It’s dependable and crowd-pleasing, the pint you can serve to anyone. If you like balance without chaos, here’s your winner.
Comforting, modern, and highly refillable.
21. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
The classic that made cookie dough a lifestyle. The vanilla base keeps things simple, letting generous dough bites shine.
Each chunk tastes like sneaking batter from the bowl, safely.
It’s nostalgic, comforting, and somehow still exciting. You’ll chase the next dough piece like a treasure hunter.
If you’ve ever loved baking nights, this pint is the memory keeper you want on standby.
22. Vanilla Caramel Fudge
Vanilla Caramel Fudge is calm with a little drama. The vanilla base is clean, almost palate-cleansing.
Caramel brings buttery sweetness, while fudge swirls add chocolate depth without heaviness.
It’s for folks who want sweet but not chaotic. Every scoop tastes tidy yet satisfying, with ribbons that keep it interesting.
A perfect companion to brownies, pies, or solo couch sessions.
