13 Michigan Fudge Shops Serving Peanut Butter Perfection
Michigan knows how to make fudge that melts hearts and taste buds alike. From the famous shops on Mackinac Island to hidden gems across the state, creamy peanut butter fudge has become a true Michigan tradition.
Whether you’re planning a summer vacation or just dreaming of sweet treats, these incredible spots serve up fudge that’s worth every delicious bite.
1. Murdick’s Fudge On Mackinac Island
Since 1887, this legendary shop has been making visitors weak in the knees with their handmade confections.
Walking past their storefront windows, you’ll watch skilled candy makers pour hot fudge onto marble slabs, creating magic right before your eyes.
Their peanut butter fudge combines smooth, creamy textures with rich nutty flavors that have kept families coming back for generations of summer vacations.
2. Ryba’s Fudge Shops On Mackinac Island
Four generations of the Ryba family have perfected their secret recipe, turning simple ingredients into pure happiness.
Each batch gets hand-stirred and cooled on copper tables, creating that perfect creamy consistency everyone craves.
Locals joke that you can smell their peanut butter fudge from three blocks away, and honestly, that’s probably what draws half the tourists to the island each summer.
3. JoAnn’s Fudge In Multiple Locations
Smart cookies, these folks figured out that great fudge shouldn’t be limited to just one spot.
With locations on both Mackinac Island and Mackinaw City, they’ve made it easier for fudge lovers to get their fix without taking a ferry ride.
Their peanut butter variety strikes the perfect balance between sweet and salty, creating addiction-level cravings that have customers planning return trips before they’ve even finished their first piece.
4. May’s Fudge On Mackinac Island
Don’t let the simple name fool you because May’s packs serious flavor punch into every square inch of their creations.
Their peanut butter fudge gets made fresh daily using traditional methods that create incredibly smooth, melt-in-your-mouth textures.
Visitors often say this place feels like stepping into grandma’s kitchen, complete with the warm, welcoming atmosphere and treats that taste like pure childhood memories.
5. Frankenmuth Fudge Kitchen In Frankenmuth
Bavarian charm meets American candy-making excellence at this delightful shop in Michigan’s Little Bavaria.
Between exploring the town’s German heritage and chicken dinners, visitors discover fudge that rivals anything found up north.
Their peanut butter recipe incorporates locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, creating rich, creamy squares that perfectly complement a day spent wandering through this unique cultural destination.
6. Kilwins In Petoskey And Beyond
Started right here in Michigan, Kilwins has grown into a beloved chain while keeping their commitment to quality intact.
Petoskey’s location offers stunning views of Little Traverse Bay along with fudge that tastes like vacation in edible form.
Their peanut butter fudge gets made using vintage copper kettles and traditional techniques, proving that some things really don’t need fixing when they’re already perfect.
7. Marshall’s Fudge In Mackinaw City
Located on the mainland side of the straits, Marshall’s gives visitors a taste of island magic without the boat ride.
Their storefront becomes a beacon for road-trippers heading north, offering the perfect excuse to stretch legs and satisfy sweet tooth cravings.
Each batch of peanut butter fudge gets cut into generous squares that provide serious bang for your buck, making this spot popular with families feeding multiple fudge enthusiasts.
8. Devon’s Mackinac Island Fudge Co. In St. Ignace
Bringing island-style fudge to the Upper Peninsula, Devon’s creates authentic treats with serious northern Michigan flair.
Their location serves as the perfect stop for travelers exploring the UP or catching ferries to Mackinac Island.
The peanut butter fudge here tastes remarkably similar to what you’d find on the island itself, but with shorter lines and easier parking that locals absolutely appreciate.
9. Murray Hotel Fudge Company On Mackinac Island
Connected to one of the island’s historic hotels, this shop combines lodging convenience with seriously impressive candy-making skills.
Hotel guests often joke about the dangerous proximity of world-class fudge to their rooms, leading to midnight snack adventures.
Their peanut butter creation features an extra creamy texture that pairs beautifully with coffee from the hotel restaurant, creating the ultimate breakfast indulgence for vacation mornings.
10. Alice’s Kandy Korn In Mackinaw City
Despite the name suggesting corn-based treats, Alice’s creates incredible fudge that keeps visitors coming back year after year.
Their shop has become a beloved tradition for families making annual trips to northern Michigan, with kids growing up on their sweet creations.
The peanut butter fudge here gets made with extra attention to achieving that perfect consistency, resulting in pieces that hold together beautifully while melting smoothly on your tongue.
11. Fudge Du Locke In Sault Ste. Marie
Way up at the locks connecting Lakes Superior and Huron, this shop creates sweet treats worthy of the engineering marvel nearby.
Visitors watching massive ships pass through often grab fudge for the perfect snack during their sightseeing adventures.
Their peanut butter recipe incorporates a hint of sea salt that enhances the nutty flavors while creating an addictive contrast that keeps tourists talking long after they’ve headed home.
12. Drummond Island Fudge Company On Drummond Island
Remote doesn’t mean compromising on quality, as this island gem proves with every batch of handcrafted fudge they create.
Accessible only by ferry, Drummond Island offers visitors a true escape from mainland hustle and bustle.
Their peanut butter fudge provides the perfect sweet ending to days spent fishing, hiking, or simply enjoying the peaceful island atmosphere that makes this destination feel like a hidden treasure.
13. Donckers In Marquette
Operating since 1896, this Upper Peninsula institution has been satisfying sweet tooths longer than most towns have existed.
Located in Marquette’s historic downtown, Donckers combines old-world charm with modern candy-making excellence that draws visitors from across the region.
Their peanut butter fudge represents over a century of recipe refinement, creating smooth, rich flavors that showcase why some traditions never go out of style.
