15 Budget-Friendly Steakhouses With Generous Portions In New York

New York City is known for its vibrant culinary scene, and steakhouses play a significant part in it. However, enjoying a hearty steak meal doesn’t have to break the bank. These 15 budget-friendly steakhouses offer generous portions and a satisfying experience without the hefty price tag.

1. St. Anselm – Williamsburg, Brooklyn

In Williamsburg, St. Anselm stands out with its rustic charm, offering a butcher’s steak that’s both rich and generously sized. The lack of white tablecloths adds to its down-to-earth appeal.

Paired with shareable sides like spinach gratin, this steakhouse ensures a great meal without the Manhattan price tag. It’s a local favorite for good reason.

The relaxed atmosphere complements the hearty dishes perfectly, making it a must-visit for steak enthusiasts.

2. Skirt Steak – Chelsea / Midtown, Manhattan

Skirt Steak in Chelsea focuses on simplicity with a fixed-price menu featuring skirt steak, salad, and unlimited fries. It feels like a luxury experience without the luxury price.

The dessert cart adds an indulgent touch, making it feel like a special night out. The all-you-can-eat fries seal the deal for a satisfying meal.

This spot is perfect for those seeking quality without compromise, right in the heart of Manhattan.

3. Knickerbocker Bar & Grill – Greenwich Village, Manhattan

With its old-school wood paneling and live jazz, Knickerbocker Bar & Grill offers a classic New York steakhouse vibe. The 28-ounce T-bone is a crowd favorite.

Known for large portions and moderate prices, it’s a staple for those seeking comfort food with a side of nostalgia. This spot has been delighting diners since the 1970s.

It’s where history and hearty meals meet, making it a Greenwich Village gem.

4. Hunter’s Steak & Ale House – Bay Ridge, Brooklyn

Hunter’s in Bay Ridge combines the vibe of an Irish pub with a steakhouse, serving hefty steaks at modest prices. The neighborhood feel adds to its charm.

Mashed potatoes and a drink complete the satisfying meal without feeling extravagant. This local favorite has been thriving for decades.

It’s the go-to spot for those looking for a relaxed atmosphere and fulfilling portions.

5. Buenos Aires – East Village, Manhattan

Buenos Aires in East Village brings Argentinian steakhouse traditions with big portions and vibrant flavors. The parrillada mixed grill is perfect for groups.

Chimichurri sauce adds a flavorful kick, making each bite memorable. The budget-friendly prices are a bonus.

It offers a lively dining experience that captures the essence of Argentinian cuisine.

6. Meet the Meat – Astoria, Queens

In Astoria, Meet the Meat provides a laid-back steakhouse experience with quality steaks in generous portions. It’s praised for its affordability compared to Manhattan counterparts.

The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make it a neighborhood favorite. It’s a spot where value meets taste.

Perfect for a casual dinner with friends or family, it’s a go-to for steak lovers in Queens.

7. Empire Steak House – Midtown / Times Square, Manhattan

Empire Steak House in Midtown offers an upscale feel with a focus on value. Large-format steaks and family-style sides make sharing a pleasure.

Dressing up for a night here feels special, yet the reasonable prices ensure you get your money’s worth. It’s an ideal choice for a classy night out.

This steakhouse bridges the gap between luxury and affordability.

8. Delmonico’s Italian Steakhouse – Albany, Syracuse, Rochester

Delmonico’s Italian Steakhouse embraces Italian-American comfort with large portions of pasta and steak. It’s a hit among families and groups.

The reasonable prices make it accessible for a casual yet indulgent meal. The Italian flair adds a unique twist.

It’s the perfect blend of hearty meals and friendly atmosphere across its locations.

9. Black & Blue Steak & Crab – Rochester, Buffalo, Albany

Black & Blue offers a more polished dining experience, with hand-cut, dry-aged steaks. Despite its upscale vibe, it’s considered a good value.

Pairing steaks with seafood creates a memorable meal. Sharing starters and sides enhances the dining experience.

For a touch of elegance without the extreme cost, Black & Blue is a favorite.

10. Nolans on Canandaigua Lake – Canandaigua

Nolans on Canandaigua Lake offers Certified Angus Beef with a lakeside view, adding a unique charm. Main dishes are priced around $30 and under.

The casual setting and quality offerings make it a hit among locals. Expect leftovers with the generous portions.

It’s a fine-dining experience without the typical expense, in a picturesque location.

11. J&R’s Steakhouse – Calverton & Islip, Long Island

J&R’s Steakhouse on Long Island presents classic steakhouse comfort with large plates like prime rib. Prices remain family-friendly.

The casual ambiance ensures everyone feels welcome. It’s a staple for those seeking a satisfying steak night out.

For a hearty meal with a cozy vibe, J&R’s is the place to be.

12. Char Steakhouse & Bar – Hudson Valley

Char Steakhouse in Hudson Valley is known for old-school vibes and actual deals. Prix-fixe dinners and prime rib specials delight patrons.

The unlimited salad bar adds to the feast, making it a budget-conscious choice. The classic decor enhances the retro feel.

For a traditional steakhouse experience, Char is an excellent choice.

13. LongHorn Steakhouse – Various Locations Across New York

LongHorn Steakhouse, despite being a chain, consistently provides value with lunch plates starting under ten bucks. The focus on affordability is evident.

Hearty sides and frequent promotions make it accessible for everyone. It’s a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.

The consistent quality across locations keeps diners coming back.

14. Texas Roadhouse – Multiple New York Locations

Texas Roadhouse embraces Texas-sized portions and a lively atmosphere. Combo dinners and family packs provide great value.

Known for big rolls and steaks, it’s a hit among families and groups. The reasonable prices are an added bonus.

It’s a place where you can enjoy a lot without spending a lot.

15. SEAR Steakhouse – Buffalo

SEAR Steakhouse in Buffalo offers a polished dining experience while keeping some items in an approachable price range.

The quality execution of affordable steaks makes it a standout. It’s perfect for those seeking a night out without the high-end cost.

For a refined yet budget-friendly steak dinner, SEAR delivers.