20 Ohio Pizzerias That Are Community Favorites
Ohio loves pizza, and the best slices are often found in the places neighbors recommend. These community favorites have stories baked into their crusts, with traditions you can taste in every bite.
From crispy squares to cheesy folds, each spot brings its own flavor of hospitality and pride. Ready to find your next go to pie and feel like a regular from the first visit?
1. Mikey’s Late Night Slice – Columbus
Columbus nights feel brighter when a giant slice hits your plate at Mikey’s. The crust is foldable with a satisfying chew, and the toppings go from classic pepperoni to quirky, late night experiments.
You grab a picnic table, swap bites with friends, and instantly get why everyone recommends it.
The secret sauce has zing, and the garlic knot vibes carry through every slice. Expect a friendly line, quick service, and a playlist that somehow improves the flavor.
It is casual, fun, and perfect after a show. Order extra ranch, grab napkins, and lean into the mess.
2. Tommy’s Pizza – Upper Arlington
Tommy’s feels like the kind of place your grandparents praised and your friends swear by. The cracker thin crust snaps cleanly, and the square cut layout makes sharing easy.
Pepperoni curls just right, and the sauce tastes bright and balanced. You sit down, relax, and time slows a little.
Servers remember faces and orders, which makes each visit feel personal. Add a salad and cold soda, then watch pies parade from the oven.
It is an Upper Arlington staple for pre game dinners and easy weeknights. You leave full, happy, and plotting your next visit.
3. Sally’s Apizza – Cincinnati Outpost
New Haven style in Ohio feels like a treat, and this Sally’s outpost nails the char. The crust blisters beautifully, giving each bite smoky depth.
Order a plain pie to appreciate the sauce, then add garlic or pepperoni for punch. You taste tradition carried across state lines, still confident and simple.
Lines form early, so plan ahead and bring patience. Staff moves fast and friendly, turning out pies with that signature chew.
The room hums with pizza talk and satisfied nods. You leave with blackened fingertips and a grin that lasts blocks.
4. Harlow’s Pizza – Worthington
Harlow’s brings a chef’s touch to neighborhood pizza. The dough is airy, blistered, and tender, with toppings that change with Ohio seasons.
You might catch hot honey drips, farm greens, or smoky sausage, all balanced perfectly. The dining room is bright and calm, ideal for lingering conversations.
Staff explains flavors without pretense, which helps you try something new. Pair a pie with a craft beer or spritz and let the crust crackle softly.
It is a Worthington gem where simple things feel special. Save room for dessert, because you will want another bite of something sweet.
5. Luigi’s Restaurant – Akron
Luigi’s is Akron comfort in pizza form. The pie arrives bubbling with a blanket of cheese that stretches forever.
Crust is sturdy, sauce leans slightly sweet, and the vibe is pure nostalgia. You can almost hear decades of stories bouncing off those walls while you take your first bite.
Locals know late night lines are worth it. Salads pile high with shredded cheese, and the jukebox adds charm.
Bring cash and a hearty appetite. It is the kind of place you recommend without hesitation, where every visit feels like returning to a favorite family tradition.
6. Rubino’s Pizza – Bexley
Rubino’s keeps it old school in the best way. Ultra thin crust, square cut, and lightly sauced, the pies are crisp and addictive.
You order at the counter, chat with regulars, and watch boxes stack up. It is straightforward, consistent, and beloved for family nights and quick carryout.
The flavor is clean and comforting, with just enough char at the edge. Pepperoni and mushrooms shine here, no frills needed.
Prices feel fair, and the rhythm is smooth. You leave with a hot box that perfumes the car, promising a perfect couch dinner.
7. Adriatico’s – Columbus Campus
Adriatico’s powers study sessions and celebrations alike. The thick Sicilian style squares come with caramelized edges that crunch beautifully.
Sauce is zesty, cheese generous, and toppings stacked. You grab napkins and dive in, because this is hearty pizza that does not apologize.
Expect a lively crowd on game days and late nights. Delivery moves fast, and carryout is a campus ritual.
The hot honey pepperoni is a sleeper hit. Whether you are cramming or catching up with friends, Adriatico’s feels like the reliable friend who always shows up with pizza and energy.
8. Geraci’s Slice Shop – Cleveland
Geraci’s Slice Shop brings classic New York style swagger to Cleveland. Slices are big, foldable, and satisfyingly salty, with a sauce that pops.
The cheese pull is real, and a sprinkle of oregano sets it off. You stand, fold, and grin after that first perfect bite.
Service is quick, and the menu keeps choices focused. Pepperoni cups char at the edges, adding smoky crunch.
Grab a soda, claim a spot by the window, and people watch. It is a straightforward stop that turns into a habit, especially when lunch needs to be quick and great.
9. Crust – Tremont
Crust in Tremont nails that artisan neighborhood sweet spot. The dough gets a slow ferment, giving depth and chew.
Toppings feel chef driven without getting fussy, from peppery greens to spicy sausage. You sip a drink, share a pie, and talk about which slice was best.
Servers know the menu and guide you toward favorites. The room glows softly, making it easy to settle in.
Add a salad for crunch and balance. It is the kind of place you return to for birthdays, weeknights, and everything between, always confident the pizza will land just right.
10. Avalanche Pizza – Athens
Athens loves Avalanche for its imagination. The menu runs wild in the best way, with flavor combos that should not work but do.
Crust has reliable structure, letting bold sauces and cheeses shine. You order something new and feel adventurous without risking dinner.
Late nights stay busy with students and locals mingling. Vegan and gluten free options are handled thoughtfully.
The staff’s enthusiasm is contagious, and you feel welcomed fast. It is a must stop when visiting Ohio University, especially when you crave a pie that surprises without sacrificing comfort and craveability.
11. Goodfella’s Pizzeria – Covington to Cincinnati crowd
Goodfella’s draws Cincinnati night owls with massive slices and fast service. The crust folds neatly, sauce leans savory, and cheese coverage is spot on.
You stand at a high top, swap stories, and inhale a slice that hits perfectly after a show. The energy makes the food taste even better.
Prices are friendly, and lines move with quick confidence. Pepperoni cups with char add crunch and smoke.
Grab a second slice if you are honest with yourself. It is a dependable stop where city buzz meets straightforward pizza pleasure, bridging the river crowd with one hot box.
12. GoreMade Pizza – Columbus
GoreMade started as a mobile oven and kept its community spirit. Pies bubble with wood fired character, topped with local produce and thoughtful sauces.
You taste smoke, sweetness, and tang in balanced harmony. The patio, with string lights and laughter, makes everything feel like a neighborhood party.
Staff encourages tasting and sharing, which makes ordering fun. Seasonal specials keep regulars curious.
Grab a cider or beer, watch the oven dance, and let conversation stretch. It is the kind of place where strangers become friends over a pie, and kids learn to love charred crust.
13. SAMOSKY’S HOMEMADE PIZZA – Parma
Samoksy’s feels like a hug in pizza form. The pan crust rises fluffy with buttery edges, soaking in just enough sauce.
Cheese melts into a gooey blanket, and toppings come generous. You taste a family recipe refined over decades, with kindness baked into the service.
Carryout is king, though the dining area feels cozy and welcoming. Specials help feed a crowd without stress.
You grab extra napkins and a side of sauce for dipping. It is a Parma staple that neighbors recommend with a smile, perfect for weeknights and birthday spreads alike.
14. Terita’s Pizza – Columbus North Side
Terita’s runs on tradition and speed. The crust is thin and crisp with a gentle chew, cut into shareable squares that disappear quickly.
Sauce tastes bright, cheese browns nicely, and pepperoni adds that classic curl. You call ahead, swing by, and leave with a hot box minutes later.
Regulars praise the consistency and fair prices. The staff works like a well oiled machine, smiling through rushes.
It feels like a neighborhood heartbeat, steady and trusted. When dinner needs to be easy and undeniably good, Terita’s quietly delivers every time without fuss.
15. A Tavola – Cincinnati
A Tavola celebrates Neapolitan finesse without feeling precious. The crust puffs with leopard spots, light yet satisfying.
A margherita shows off balanced tomatoes and creamy mozzarella, while specialty pies add playful heat and sweetness. You tear a slice, breathe in basil, and taste careful technique.
Drinks are crafted thoughtfully, which makes lingering easy. Staff guides you through dough, bake, and toppings with confidence.
The space hums on date nights and group gatherings. When you want elegance wrapped in comfort, A Tavola makes pizza feel like an occasion without losing warmth.
16. Vero Pizza Napoletana – Cleveland Heights
Vero specializes in careful simplicity. The dough rests patiently, bakes fast, and emerges blistered yet tender.
Tomatoes sing, mozzarella melts softly, and basil finishes fragrant. You eat with knife and fork or fold, either way savoring balance and lightness that keeps you wanting one more slice.
Service is warm but efficient, and the menu stays focused. Specials highlight seasonal ingredients without distraction.
Pair with a glass of wine and enjoy the calm. It is the neighborhood spot that teaches you to slow down and taste every detail in the crust and sauce.
17. Pizza Cottage – Lancaster
Pizza Cottage brings hearty Midwest comfort to the table. Crust is thicker at the rim, perfect for grabbing, while the center stays balanced under generous toppings.
Sauce leans savory, and cheese stretches playfully. You come with a group, fill the booth, and pass plates back and forth happily.
Service keeps things moving and friendly. Specials make feeding a crowd straightforward.
Add breadsticks and extra sauce, because dipping is half the joy. It is the Lancaster go to for team dinners, casual birthdays, and Tuesday nights when everyone wants leftovers for lunch tomorrow.
18. Enzo’s Pizza – Dayton
Enzo’s focuses on honest, tasty pizza without theatrics. The crust lands between thin and hearty, holding toppings confidently.
Pepperoni cups crisp at the edges, and the sauce adds a gentle tang. You grab a booth, sip a fountain drink, and feel like a local by the second slice.
Prices are fair, and lunch specials hit the spot. Staff greets regulars by name, building that neighborhood rhythm.
Carryout is quick for busy nights. When you crave dependable flavor and zero fuss, Enzo’s quietly gets it done, sending you home with a hot box and a smile.
19. Harvest Pizzeria – German Village
Harvest balances comfort and creativity with ease. The crust has a tender chew and charred edge, carrying toppings like fennel sausage, hot honey, and seasonal vegetables.
Sauces taste bright and clean, making every slice feel intentional. You split a pie and a salad, then talk about ordering a second.
Servers are attentive without hovering, guiding you through pairings. Cocktails complement the pies, keeping the evening relaxed.
The space has historic charm that feels warm year round. When you want a thoughtful meal that still feels casual, Harvest delivers with precision and heart.
20. Carleone’s Pizza – Youngstown Area
Carleone’s serves sturdy, satisfying pies that speak Youngstown fluently. Expect a robust crust, a generous blanket of cheese, and toppings that do not skimp.
Sauce leans savory with a hint of sweetness. You sit down, exhale, and let the day soften while that first slice works its magic.
Families fill booths, and staff moves with practiced kindness. Carryout boxes stack quickly on Fridays.
Add extra sauce for dipping and a side salad. It is the pizza you crave when you need comfort, the kind neighbors recommend because it never lets them down on busy weeknights.
