10 Best Pie Shops In Tennessee Baking Sweet Memories Every Day
Nothing beats a slice of homemade pie, especially when you’re traveling through Tennessee.
The Volunteer State is home to some incredible bakeries where pastry chefs craft flaky crusts and mouthwatering fillings daily.
Are you ready? Because these 10 pie shops represent the best of Tennessee’s sweet scene.
1. Pie Sensations: Where Flavor Meets Art
Family recipes shine at this cozy Nashville bakery where every pie tells a story. The signature peach bourbon creation draws folks from three counties over.
Weekend mornings often see lines out the door as locals stock up on take-home treats. Their mini pie sampler lets indecisive customers try multiple flavors without the guilt.
2. Baked on 8th: Small-Batch Heaven
Tucked away on 8th Avenue, this gem specializes in pies that taste like grandma’s kitchen – if grandma were a culinary genius. Their chocolate chess pie practically melts on your tongue.
The rustic-chic interior features reclaimed wood tables where customers linger over coffee and pie pairings. Seasonal ingredients mean the menu changes regularly, rewarding frequent visitors.
3. Papa C Pies Bakery: The Crust Masters
What started as a father’s hobby has blossomed into Brentwood’s pie paradise. Papa C’s crusts achieve that mythical balance – flaky yet substantial, buttery without being greasy.
Their caramel apple pie won three regional baking competitions in a single year!
Regulars swear by the strawberry rhubarb in spring and pumpkin in fall, but their signature chocolate bourbon pecan remains available year-round.
4. Brightside Bakeshop: Innovative Pie Pioneers
Forget everything you thought you knew about pie! Brightside’s adventurous bakers experiment with unexpected flavor combinations that somehow always work.
Their lavender honey pie caused such a sensation that national food magazines came calling.
5. Elliston Place Soda Shop: Nostalgic Pie Paradise
Step back in time at this Nashville institution serving classic American pies since 1939. The vintage soda fountain counter creates the perfect backdrop for enjoying their legendary meringue-topped lemon pie.
Black and white floor tiles and red vinyl booths complete the retro experience. Fourth-generation customers bring their kids for the same pie flavors their grandparents enjoyed decades ago.
6. Dozen Bakery: Artisanal Pie Perfection
French technique meets Southern hospitality at this Nashville bakery where every pie component is crafted from scratch. Their butter-laminated crusts shatter delicately with each forkful.
Natural light floods the minimalist space, highlighting the beauty of their fruit pies. The bakery sources ingredients from local farms, making their seasonal offerings a true taste of Tennessee terroir.
7. The Tennessee Cobbler Company: Rustic Pie Charm
This family-owned shop specializes in deep-dish creations that serve up hearty slices.
Mason jar chandeliers hang from wooden beams while the scent of cinnamon and sugar fills the air.
Their signature “Rocky Top” pie layers apples, pears, and blackberries under a brown sugar crumble that locals dream about.
8. Loveless Café: Where Tradition Meets Pie Excellence
Famous for their biscuits, this Nashville landmark deserves equal recognition for their spectacular pies. The chess pie recipe hasn’t changed since 1951, and for good reason – it’s perfect.
Checkered tablecloths and country charm create the ideal setting for savoring their famous desserts. Tourists and locals alike line up for a taste of their chocolate fudge pie, often taking whole pies to go.
9. Merridee’s Breadbasket: Historic Pie Destination
Located in Franklin’s historic district, Merridee’s brick-walled charm is matched only by their exceptional pies. The pecan pie features nuts from Tennessee groves, toasted to bring out their natural oils.
Morning sunlight streams through arched windows, illuminating display cases of freshly baked goods. Their buttermilk pie – tangy, sweet, and impossibly creamy – has been featured in Southern Living magazine twice.
10. Dutch Maid Bakery: Tennessee’s Oldest Pie Sanctuary
Operating since 1902, this Tracy City institution holds the title of Tennessee’s oldest bakery. German baking traditions influence their pie-making, resulting in perfectly balanced sweetness and exceptional texture.
The original brick ovens still produce pies daily! Their sour cream apple pie combines unexpected tanginess with traditional flavors, creating a unique treat that’s worth the drive to this small mountain town.
