7 North Dakota Pie Shops That Bring Back Grandma’s Kitchen Comfort
Nothing quite compares to the warm, buttery smell of fresh pie cooling on a windowsill, just like Grandma used to make.
North Dakota is home to some seriously charming pie shops that deliver that same cozy, heartfelt magic with every slice.
1. Kroll’s Diner
Step up to this iconic Bismarck landmark and you’ll instantly feel transported back to simpler times. The exterior screams classic Americana with its vintage charm and welcoming vibe that practically begs you to come inside.
Once you taste their homemade pies, you’ll understand why locals have been lining up for decades. Each slice is baked with love and served with a side of genuine North Dakota hospitality that feels just like visiting your favorite grandma.
313 E Main Ave, Bismarck, ND 58501
2. The Toasted Frog
Fargo’s beloved culinary gem sits proudly on Broadway, its inviting exterior hinting at the comfort food treasures waiting inside. While known for creative contemporary dishes, their dessert menu absolutely shines with pie selections that honor traditional recipes.
Every bite delivers that perfect balance of flaky crust and rich filling your grandmother would approve of wholeheartedly. The atmosphere blends modern style with old-fashioned warmth, making every visit feel special and memorable.
124 Broadway N, Fargo, ND 58102
3. Pirogue Grille
Looking at this Bismarck favorite from the outside, you might not guess the incredible homestyle desserts hiding within its walls. But locals know better, and they flock here for pies that taste like they came straight from a farmhouse kitchen.
Seasonal fruit pies rotate throughout the year, always made with fresh ingredients and traditional techniques that honor generations of baking wisdom. The creamy, dreamy textures will have you closing your eyes in pure bliss.
1601 River Rd, Bismarck, ND 58503
4. Paradiso Mexican Restaurant
Who says pie has to be all-American? This Grand Forks hotspot puts a delightful twist on dessert traditions with offerings that bridge cultures beautifully. Their exterior welcomes guests with vibrant energy and a promise of something uniquely satisfying.
While you might come for the tacos, staying for dessert is absolutely mandatory here. Sweet treats with cinnamon-kissed flavors and creamy textures evoke that same comforting feeling Grandma’s kitchen always delivered, just with a delicious cultural spin.
1210 N 43rd St, Grand Forks, ND 58203
5. The Walrus Restaurant
Housed in a charming building that catches your eye immediately, this Bismarck treasure has been serving comfort food with soul for years. The outside alone promises good things, and the dessert menu absolutely delivers on that promise.
Their pie selections change with the seasons, but the commitment to quality never wavers one bit. Each slice arrives at your table looking picture-perfect and tasting even better, with flavors that wrap around you like a warm kitchen hug.
1000 E Interstate Ave, Bismarck, ND 58503
6. Rhombus Guys Pizza
Pizza might be their main game, but don’t sleep on the dessert offerings at this Fargo favorite with multiple locations. From the street, the modern exterior looks casual and fun, perfectly matching the relaxed vibe inside.
Finish your meal with one of their sweet pies and you’ll discover why regulars always save room for dessert here. The recipes feel homemade and heartfelt, bringing back memories of family gatherings and kitchen table conversations that lasted for hours.
3001 25th St S, Fargo, ND 58103
7. The Starving Rooster
Just across the river in Mandan, this charming spot greets visitors with a welcoming exterior that promises hearty, honest food. Inside, the menu focuses on breakfast and lunch comfort classics, with desserts that steal the show completely.
Their pies are baked fresh daily using recipes that feel like family secrets passed down through generations. One forkful and you’ll taste the difference that comes from genuine care, quality ingredients, and a passion for feeding people well.
2454 Old Red Trl, Mandan, ND 58554
