17 Best Pizza Spots In Fort Lauderdale, Florida That Prove It’s A Pizza Lover’s Town
Fort Lauderdale has become a hidden paradise for pizza lovers.
Authentic Italian-style crusts or unique American creations, this sunny city offers amazing pizza options for every taste.
Ready to discover where locals and tourists alike satisfy their pizza cravings? Here’s our handpicked list of the absolute best pizza spots in Fort Lauderdale.
1. Heritage: Where History Meets Modern Flavors
Located in a charming historic building, Heritage blends old-world techniques with contemporary twists. Their wood-fired oven creates that perfect char on thin, chewy crusts.
The farm-to-table ingredients shine through in every bite – try their prosciutto and fig pizza for a sweet-savory explosion. Family-owned and community-focused, it’s no wonder locals keep coming back.
2. Mister O1: Star-Shaped Pizza That Dazzles
Mister O1’s star-shaped pizzas aren’t just Instagram-worthy – they’re culinary masterpieces! Each pointy corner holds a ricotta-filled pocket that’ll make your taste buds dance with joy.
Originally a Miami sensation, their Fort Lauderdale location brings the same extraordinary flavors to Las Olas. The Star Luca with spicy salami and honey is absolutely life-changing.
3. Louie Bossi’s: Italian Grandma-Approved Pies
Mama mia! Louie Bossi’s transports you straight to an Italian grandmother’s kitchen. Their dough ferments for 72 hours, creating that addictive chew pizza aficionados crave.
Beyond pizza, the vibrant atmosphere and gorgeous patio make this a date-night favorite.
Can’t decide what to order? The Margherita showcases their perfect balance of simplicity and flavor – sometimes less really is more!
4. Times Square Pizza: New York Slices in the Sunshine State
Homesick New Yorkers, rejoice! Times Square Pizza delivers authentic Big Apple slices without the subway fare. The massive, foldable slices have that perfect crisp-yet-chewy texture.
Grab a slice to go or settle in at this no-frills joint. Their pepperoni cup and curl just the right way, creating tiny pools of delicious flavor. Late-night pizza cravings? They’ve got you covered until midnight!
5. Pizza Craft: Artisanal Creations in Historic Himmarshee
Nestled in Fort Lauderdale’s historic district, Pizza Craft lives up to its name with truly crafted pies. Their sourdough crust develops incredible flavor during a 48-hour cold fermentation process.
Adventurous eaters should try the short rib pizza with caramelized onions and horseradish cream. The cozy brick interior and craft cocktail menu make this spot perfect for both casual lunches and special occasions.
6. Patio Bar & Pizza: Beachside Slices with Ocean Views
Sand between your toes and pizza in your hand – life doesn’t get better than Patio Bar & Pizza! Just steps from the beach, this casual spot serves vacation vibes alongside crispy-bottomed pies.
The seafood pizza topped with fresh local catches changes daily based on what’s available.
Cold beer, ocean breezes, and friendly staff complete the perfect Florida pizza experience that keeps beach-goers coming back day after day.
7. Primanti Bros.: Pittsburgh Meets Florida with Sandwich-Sized Slices
Famous for their sandwiches stuffed with fries, Primanti Bros. also makes surprisingly fantastic pizza! Their thick-cut slices are almost meal-sized, perfect after a night exploring Fort Lauderdale’s nightlife.
Open 24 hours on weekends, it’s the late-night pizza hero we all need. The Steak Supreme pizza combines their sandwich and pizza expertise with thinly-sliced steak, cheese, and yes – even a few fries on top!
8. Umberto’s: Old-School Italian That Never Disappoints
Red-checkered tablecloths and chianti bottles set the scene at Umberto’s, a Fort Lauderdale classic since 1985.
The pizza arrives on those metal stands that instantly transport you to childhood Italian restaurant memories. Their sauce has a secret sweetness that locals have tried (and failed) to replicate for decades.
Generous with cheese and toppings, you’ll need to bring your appetite – or plan for delicious leftovers tomorrow morning!
9. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza: Perfectly Charred Since 2002
Coal-fired ovens reaching 800 degrees create Anthony’s signature well-done crust – crispy, slightly blackened, and absolutely addictive.
Their “Italian Soul Food” approach extends beyond pizza to coal-fired wings and meatballs. The simplicity of their Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato pie lets quality ingredients shine.
With multiple locations throughout Fort Lauderdale, there’s always an Anthony’s nearby when those coal-fired cravings hit!
10. Blue Steel Pizza Co.: Detroit-Style Squares Taking Over Florida
Motor City meets the Venice of America at Blue Steel Pizza Co.! Their Detroit-style pies feature that irresistible caramelized cheese edge that forms a crispy border around fluffy, focaccia-like dough.
The “Blue Steel Special” comes loaded with pepperoni that cups up, creating tiny pools of savory goodness.
Industrial-chic décor and craft beers on tap make this trendy spot perfect for gathering with friends before hitting Las Olas nightlife.
11. Chicago Stuffed Pizza Co.: Deep Dish Dreams Come True
Windy City natives swear this is the most authentic Chicago deep dish outside Illinois! Each pizza is a towering achievement that requires 40 minutes to bake to perfection.
Layers of cheese, toppings, and that distinctive cornmeal-dusted crust create a knife-and-fork experience worth waiting for.
12. Emmy Squared Pizza: Brooklyn’s Detroit-Style Sensation
Emmy Squared brings Brooklyn hipster vibes to Fort Lauderdale with their award-winning Detroit-style squares.
The “Colony” – their signature pie with pepperoni, pickled jalapeños and honey – creates a sweet-spicy-savory trifecta you’ll dream about. Don’t sleep on their incredible burger either!
The photogenic restaurant with neon signs and hanging plants attracts a trendy crowd, so weekend reservations are highly recommended for this pizza hotspot.
13. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana: Connecticut Legend Heads South
Pizza history comes alive at Frank Pepe’s! This legendary Connecticut institution (established 1925) finally brought their coal-fired magic to Fort Lauderdale, and pizza purists are rejoicing.
The White Clam Pizza – their signature creation – features fresh clams, garlic, oregano, and no sauce. Coal-fired ovens create that distinctive char impossible to replicate at home.
Expect lines on weekends, but the pizza pilgrimage is absolutely worth it.
14. Sicilian Oven: Wood-Fired Wonders in a Family Setting
Gather the whole family at Sicilian Oven, where wood-fired pizzas emerge from blazing hot ovens with perfect leopard-spotted crusts.
The neighborhood vibe makes everyone feel welcome – from kids to grandparents. Beyond traditional options, try their Potato & Rosemary pie with paper-thin potato slices and fragrant herbs.
The garlic knots are legendary too, arriving at your table hot and glistening with garlic-herb butter that’s utterly irresistible.
15. Luigi’s Coal Oven Pizza: Certified Neapolitan Excellence
Authenticity reigns supreme at Luigi’s, one of the few Fort Lauderdale pizzerias certified by the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana.
Their imported Italian wood-burning oven creates that signature soft, chewy center with charred bubbles around the rim. Imported 00 flour and San Marzano tomatoes honor traditional methods.
The bustling open kitchen lets you watch pizza artists stretching dough and sliding pies into the blazing oven – dinner and a show!
16. Monti’s Italian Pizzeria: Neighborhood Gem with Loyal Following
Sometimes the best pizza comes from unassuming strip mall locations – Monti’s proves this theory! This family-owned treasure has served loyal locals for over 25 years.
The owners know regulars by name and often remember their usual orders. Their sauce has a distinctive herbal profile that sets it apart from chain competitors.
The garlic rolls alone are worth the visit – pillowy soft inside with garlic butter clinging to every crevice.
17. Big Louie’s Pizzeria: Mammoth Slices for Mammoth Appetites
“Go big or go home” is the unofficial motto at Big Louie’s, where the 24-inch pies challenge even the hungriest pizza lovers. Their jumbo slices barely fit on standard paper plates!
Despite the massive size, the thin crust stays remarkably crisp.
The walls covered in sports memorabilia and the buzzing atmosphere make this a perfect casual hangout spot.
