20 New York Restaurants Actually Recommend

Explore a curated list of 20 standout dining experiences in New York, from legendary delis to trendy new hotspots, each offering a unique taste of the city’s vibrant food scene.

1. Katz’s Delicatessen – Lower East Side, Manhattan

Katz’s Delicatessen is the quintessential New York deli. With its towering pastrami on rye and half-sour pickles, it offers a dining experience that’s both chaotic and charming.

The shouted-ticket system adds to its unique energy, making it a must-visit for those seeking an authentic deli experience. Locals may not frequent it weekly, but when they crave a classic, this is the place.

Whether it’s the nostalgia or the unbeatable flavor, Katz’s holds a special place in New York’s culinary heart.

2. Russ & Daughters Cafe – Lower East Side, Manhattan

At Russ & Daughters Cafe, smoked fish and bagels are transformed into an art form. This cafe excels in bringing old-world care to every dish, from caviar to egg creations.

It’s a brunch destination that lives up to its reputation, offering diners a true taste of “Jewish appetizing.”

Whether for a special occasion or a casual brunch, locals appreciate the cafe’s dedication to quality and tradition.

3. Di Fara Pizza – Midwood, Brooklyn

Di Fara Pizza is a pilgrimage spot for pizza aficionados. Known for its olive oil-brushed crusts and fresh basil toppings, each pie is a masterpiece.

While neither cheap nor fast, the first bite justifies the wait, making it a beloved spot for locals and visitors. The combination of cheeses adds a distinctive flavor.

A trip to Di Fara is more than a meal; it’s an experience that celebrates the art of pizza-making.

4. L’Industrie Pizzeria – Williamsburg, Brooklyn

L’Industrie Pizzeria stands out with its crisp, thin pies topped with imaginative ingredients like burrata and figs. Despite the creative toppings, the pizzas never feel gimmicky.

Locals are happy to wait in line for a taste, as the crust, cheese, and toppings blend seamlessly.

This spot is a testament to how innovation and tradition can coexist, offering a modern twist on a classic favorite.

5. Lucali – Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

At Lucali, the focus is on simple perfection. This cash-only, low-light pizzeria serves blistered thin-crust pizzas and calzones that are worth the wait.

Patrons bring their own wine, adding to the intimate atmosphere. The dedication to quality shines in every bite.

Lucali is a reminder that sometimes the simplest things in life are the most rewarding, especially when it comes to pizza.

6. Xi’an Famous Foods – Multiple NYC Locations

Xi’an Famous Foods started as a humble stall and grew into a beloved chain due to its addictive flavors. The hand-pulled biang-biang noodles, slicked in chili oil, are a highlight.

With dishes like cumin lamb burgers and spicy, vinegar-bright fare, it brings the flavors of China’s Shaanxi region to New York.

Its expansion is a testament to the city’s love for these intense, satisfying dishes.

7. Gramercy Tavern – Gramercy, Manhattan

Gramercy Tavern offers polished American cuisine with a neighborly feel. Whether you’re enjoying a burger in the tavern or a tasting menu in the dining room, it delivers without pretension.

The restaurant captures that “New York special-occasion” feeling, perfect for both locals and visitors.

Its ability to be both elegant and welcoming ensures it remains a staple in the city’s dining scene.

8. Le Bernardin – Midtown, Manhattan

Le Bernardin is synonymous with seafood excellence. Its white tablecloths and precise culinary techniques make it a top choice for fine dining in New York.

Locals recommend it for those seeking a classic, luxurious dinner that justifies its price tag.

Each dish is a testament to the chefs’ commitment to quality and creativity, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience.

9. Sylvia’s – Harlem, Manhattan

Sylvia’s is a Harlem institution, known for its soul food classics like fried chicken, smothered pork chops, and collards. It’s more than just a restaurant; it’s a cultural landmark.

The warm, inviting atmosphere makes diners feel like family. Locals return for both the comfort food and the community spirit.

Sylvia’s keeps the traditions of soul food alive, celebrating flavors that taste like home.

10. Joe’s Shanghai – Chinatown, Manhattan

Joe’s Shanghai introduced many New Yorkers to the joy of soup dumplings. Their xiao long bao come steaming and delicate, a must-try for any visitor.

The dining room’s joyful chaos adds to the experience. While the dumplings are the star, the rest of the menu holds its own.

It’s a place where tradition and flavor shine, making it a staple in Chinatown dining.

11. The Odeon – Tribeca, Manhattan

The Odeon is a Tribeca staple, withstanding trends and time. Its bistro vibe attracts media, artists, and regulars alike.

Diners enjoy martinis and steak frites in those iconic red banquettes, relishing the “old Tribeca” charm.

The Odeon embodies the essence of New York nightlife with its enduring appeal and classic menu.

12. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que – Syracuse (and other NY locations)

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que began as a biker joint and evolved into a beloved regional chain. Known for smoky ribs and pulled pork, it retains a lively, roadhouse vibe.

The Syracuse original is a point of pride for locals, combining great food with a fun atmosphere.

It’s a spot where barbecue and community come together in flavorful harmony.

13. Stissing House – Pine Plains (Hudson Valley)

Stissing House combines history with contemporary cuisine. This centuries-old tavern offers wood-fired dishes featuring local ingredients.

Diners enjoy roast chicken and perfect desserts in a room steeped in New York history. The ambiance feels both historic and current.

It’s a place where tradition meets modernity, offering a unique dining experience in the Hudson Valley.

14. Café Mutton – Hudson

Café Mutton is a tiny spot bursting with personality. Known for nose-to-tail cooking, it serves cozy breakfast and lunch plates.

Locals line up for house-made sausages and simple egg dishes that taste like the ideal breakfast.

With its welcoming vibe and flavorful fare, Café Mutton is a beloved part of Hudson’s culinary scene.

15. Lil’ Deb’s Oasis – Hudson

Lil’ Deb’s Oasis is part restaurant, part art project. Its bold, colorful dishes draw inspiration from Latin American flavors.

Loud, neon, and deeply beloved, it’s the go-to for those seeking fun dining over fancy fare.

The restaurant’s vibrant atmosphere and creative menu make it a standout in Hudson’s dining landscape.

16. The DeBruce – Livingston Manor (Catskills)

The DeBruce is more than a restaurant; it’s an escape. Overlooking a river, its tasting menus feature local fish, mushrooms, and wild plants.

New Yorkers book weekends here to experience a love letter to the region through food.

The DeBruce’s nature-focused cuisine and serene setting create a uniquely immersive dining experience.

17. Casa Susanna – Leeds (Catskills)

Casa Susanna is a newer name gaining attention for its thoughtful, seasonal cooking. Located in a laid-back rural setting, it’s a spot food enthusiasts rave about.

The menu highlights local ingredients, offering flavors that reflect the changing seasons.

Casa Susanna is a hidden gem in the Catskills, celebrated for its culinary creativity and relaxed vibe.

18. Silvia – Woodstock

Silvia in Woodstock combines comfort with clean eating. Its wood-fired grill and vegetable-focused menu appeal to diners seeking a post-hike meal.

The dishes are seasonal but unfussy, allowing natural flavors to shine through.

Silvia provides a refreshing culinary experience, perfect for those enjoying a long weekend upstate.

19. Good Night – Woodstock

Good Night offers a modern twist with its Southeast Asian-inspired small plates. The cozy, candlelit space is just off Woodstock’s main drag, inviting diners seeking something different.

Locals recommend it for those tired of the usual burgers and pizza.

With its exciting menu and intimate atmosphere, Good Night adds a unique flair to Woodstock dining.

20. Duff’s Famous Wings – Amherst/Buffalo Area

Duff’s Famous Wings is a staple in Buffalo’s culinary scene. Known for super-crispy wings and sauce with real heat, it’s a local favorite.

The “no nonsense, just wings and beer” approach appeals to both locals and visiting Bills fans.

Duff’s remains a must-visit for anyone exploring the Buffalo area’s famous wing culture.