Pizza Time In St. Augustine, Florida Proves Why It’s Among America’s Best
In the historic streets of St. Augustine, Florida, Pizza Time has earned a reputation that stretches far beyond the city’s borders.
Known for drawing long lines of eager customers, this spot has consistently ranked as one of the best pizza joints in the country.
With its old-world charm and a commitment to authentic flavors, Pizza Time offers an experience that feels both timeless and unforgettable.
A Slice of History: Pizza Time’s Humble Beginnings
Founded in 2012 by New York transplants with pizza-making in their blood, Pizza Time quickly became St. Augustine’s go-to spot for authentic slices.
The owners brought generations of family recipes straight from the Big Apple to Florida’s historic coast.
Their vision was simple yet powerful: serve genuine New York pizza in a place where tourists and locals could enjoy a taste of the North.
Within months, lines began forming out the door – a sight that remains common today.
Step Inside the Pizza Paradise
Pizza Time instantly greets you with the energy of a true neighborhood pizzeria, where tradition and comfort collide in the best way.
The open kitchen buzzes with action as pizza makers stretch dough sky-high before sliding it toward the oven.
All the while, the irresistible fragrance of bubbling cheese, roasted garlic, and fresh basil drifts through the air, wrapping the cozy room in warmth and making your appetite kick in long before you reach the counter.
New York Slices That Steal the Show
Pizza Time’s claim to fame? Those massive, foldable New York-style slices that barely fit on a plate!
Their secret weapon is the water – specially filtered to mimic NYC’s famous tap water, creating that distinctive chewy-yet-crispy crust.
The Meat Lovers Supreme packs pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon onto every inch.
Meanwhile, their Margherita showcases the perfect balance of fresh mozzarella, basil, and sweet tomato sauce.
Each pie emerges from old-school deck ovens with bubbling cheese and perfectly charred edges.
Local Fame and National Recognition
TripAdvisor once crowned Pizza Time as the #2 pizzeria in America – an achievement proudly displayed on their window.
During peak tourist seasons, the line often stretches down the block.
Locals know to come during off-hours or call ahead.
