When someone mentions key limes, two things automatically come to mind, Key West, Florida, and key lime pies. Key lime pie is one of the best American staples, but did you know that apart from Florida Keys’ official pie, there are also other amazing key lime dessert recipes you can try?
Whether you’re looking for different key lime pie recipes or new key lime dessert recipes to add to your menu, I’ve got you covered! I’ve scoured the internet to find some of the best key lime pie recipes and desserts that will make you drool!
If your palate is ready, let’s dig in!
This post contains links for items to purchase. I make a commission on any sales.
How Do Key Limes Differ from Other Limes?
Unlike regular limes, key limes are known for being more tart and aromatic. They are also relatively smaller, have thinner yellowish skin and more seeds.
There isn’t much distinct difference between key limes and other limes. However, its popularity for being the main ingredient on one of the best-loved American dishes just proves that it has an exceptional flavor that no other limes can match.
Can’t wait to satisfy that citrusy craving? Here’s a bunch of key lime pie recipes and other key lime dessert recipes you can try at home!
Key Lime Pie Recipes
Key lime pie is the official pie of The Florida Keys. Restaurants in Key West take pride in serving this exceptional American favorite.
If you are craving it right now, you don’t have to drive all the way to Florida to taste this yummy dessert! Check out some of these delicious and easy key lime pie recipes!
Need a little taste of summer? This key lime pie recipe uses a graham cracker pie crust, sour cream, condensed milk, sugar, cool whip, key lime juice, and zest. It's a very simple dessert that will only take 20 minutes of your time!
A fan of no-bake recipes? This key lime pie recipe won't require you to heat the oven, and it makes adorable and tasty mini frozen key lime pies! It only needs graham crackers, cream cheese, butter, condensed milk, key lime juice, and whipped topping!
A bit conscious about your health but want to enjoy the sweet and citrusy goodness of a key lime pie? This recipe is gluten-free and only needs five ingredients: egg yolks, condensed milk, heavy cream, key lime juice, and zest.
If you're a real key lime lover, this classic key lime pie is a must-try! This recipe uses homemade ingredients such as graham cracker crust and whipped cream on top, with a creamy, citrus, and sweet key lime filling.
Give your key lime pie more tropical vibes through this toasted coconut key lime pie recipe! This recipe uses coconut cookie crust and coconut whipped topping that makes this key lime pie dairy-free and even tastier!
Want to upscale your key lime pie a little? Why not try this Pappadeaux Key Lime Pie with Raspberry? You will only need to spare 30 minutes of your time for this recipe, and you will be able to create a more visually appealing and delicious pie!
This no-bake key lime pie recipe won't require you to heat the oven or even use a pie tin, because all you need to make these awesome key lime pies are jars! This key lime dessert recipe is perfect to bring on picnics and summer getaways!
Give your key lime pie a nutty twist with this recipe! If you are a nut lover and you love macadamia nuts, you shouldn't miss trying this mouthwatering and refreshing recipe! It makes a tangy, citrusy, sweet, buttery, creamy, and nutty key lime pie!
Want a fluffer, softer, and low in fats and sugar key lime pie? This recipe makes a heavenly key lime pie! It only needs five ingredients: boiling water, graham cracker crust, frozen fat-free whipped topping, sugar-free lime gelatin, and key lime yogurt!
If you really want the original taste of the Florida Keys’ key lime pie, this recipe is what you need! This recipe has easy-to-find ingredients and only requires 40 minutes of overall cooking time. Plus, it's topped with tasty meringue!
Other Key Lime Dessert Recipes
Like I said earlier, apart from key lime pies, there are plenty more key lime dessert recipes that are easy to make and super delicious!
If you want to take a break from key lime pies, but you are still craving the exceptional citrusy flavor and sweetness of key limes, here are some must-try key lime dessert recipes for you!
Share these unique, bright, flavorful, and fresh key lime cookies with your family and friends! This amazing key lime cookie recipe is perfect if you want to make a quick treat! Plus, it only requires seven ingredients: yellow cake mix, eggs, oil, lime juice, lime zest, milk, and icing sugar.
This fudge recipe is ideal if you want to have your key lime pie in bite-size pieces and serve them as a sweet treat for your weekend gathering. It makes a delicious bite of white chocolate fudge with a citrus twist!
These key lime pie cheesecake bars are a perfect and easy summer dessert! They are sweet, cheesy, creamy, and tangy! If key lime pies are simple to make, these key lime cheesecake bars are even simpler!
Who would say no to this yummy and creamy key lime pudding? It's a must on warm summer days! This key lime pudding's ingredients are heavy cream, confectioner's sugar, unsalted butter, eggs, granulated sugar, key lime zest, and key lime juice.
You won't be able to get enough of this key lime coconut angel cake once you've tasted it! It has an amazing blend of coconut and lime flavor that you haven't tasted before! Needless to say, it's also very easy to make.
This luscious key lime dessert is a real crowd pleaser! It's a great make-ahead dessert for parties and gatherings, and it only takes a total prep time of 1 and a half hours. This key lime dessert also has fresh berries as a topping that make it even more refreshing!
Another key lime pudding recipe but, this one only needs sugar-free vanilla pudding cups, whipped topping, lime juice, and crushed graham crackers! You just need to combine pudding and lime juice, sprinkle the crushed graham crackers, add whip on top, and you're all done!
Kitchen Essentials For Making Easy Desserts
Here are some highly suggested products that will surely help you in making delicious, tasty, and citrusy key lime desserts!
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.