Skip to Content

Ice Cream Pie Recipes

Sharing is caring!

Making an easy ice cream pie is simple and fun, no special equipment required! Try out all of these awesome ice cream pie recipes and scroll down to learn about how to make ice cream pie, gather some homemade ice cream pie recipes, and more!

The great thing about ice cream pie recipes is that you can prep them in advance. In most cases you will need to prep them in advance so they can freeze solid enough to be sliced and served. If you are like me and enjoy having something on hand ready to go, these recipes will be perfect!

If you don’t want to make your ice cream into pies you can always check out these no churn homemade ice cream recipes that are quick and easy as well. There’s something for everyone and every season in our collection of homemade ice cream.

This post contains links to products I like and think will be useful to you. If you click through and make a purchase I make a commission.

Pin showing the finished ice ream pie recipes and title across the middle.

What is ice cream pie?

Ice cream pie ideas like these are basically ice cream in a pie shell. You can use a crust of your choosing like graham crackers or crushed Oreo’s and then it’s even easier to make pie out of ice cream.

Essentially this is a simple way to make an ice cream cake at home that you don’t have to put frosting on top of before serving. It’s a simple way to make a frozen treat that everyone will love.

How to make ice cream pie:

Each of these recipes is a little different, some are layered, some have toppings, etc. but the general guide for how to make ice cream pie is as follows:

You will need to make your ice cream. Usually this includes a variety of dairy products, some flavorings, and maybe some fruit. Your base will be whipped in the mixer for a bit to make sure that it’s well combined and ready to be frozen without separating. This takes the place of the churning of traditional ice cream.

Next, you will add in your flavorings and mix-ins, before pouring all of that into a pie crust and popping it into the freezer.

You can top it with more ingredients before it is frozen so that it has an extra pretty appearance if you like.

When it’s frozen solid, usually about 24 hours will do the trick, you can pull it out, let it sit at room temperature for a bit, and then slice with a sharp knife!

slice of ice cream pie recipes finished and on a plate ready to serve.

Are these easy ice cream pie ideas?

Absolutely. Just because these are homemade ice ream pie recipes doesn’t mean they are difficult to make. You can use regular ice cream that is thawed down a bit so you can spread it out to make an ice cream pie but these recipes are just as easy.

There’s not a lot of complicated ingredients or processes happening so feel free to give these a try even if you aren’t the most confident person in the kitchen! Even kids can help make these tasty treats for a summer activity that is fun from start to finish.

Kitchen essentials for tasty no bake recipes:

When you head into the kitchen to make some of these great recipes you’ll want to have the best tools on hand.

Of course mixing bowls, a mixerspatula, and some whisks should be on your list if you don’t have ones that you love.

I like these casserole dishes from Pyrex which are great for no bake recipes and for all your favorite dinners, brownies, cakes, and more. Hooray for dual purpose kitchen equipment!

You can’t go wrong with some good sharp knives and a cutting board. They will always come in handy in the kitchen for recipes of any kind, even desserts!

pie topped with sliced limes

Do you have any pumpkin ice cream pie recipes?

We have an excellent homemade pumpkin spice ice cream that would make an awesome pie. Check out the full recipe for pumpkin spice no churn ice cream and see for yourself!

It’s a great addition to your fall dessert menu, just like this caramel apple ice cream recipe that would make a delicious pie.

A top down view of the finished dish ready to eat.

Ice Cream Pie Recipes:

Let’s dive on in and see what kinds of ice cream pie recipes we can whip up. There’s surely something on this list that will catch y our eye and make you want to start whipping up ice cream recipes at home. If you have little ones that like to help in the kitchen these are great options because there’s not much in the way of dangerous processes happening, no heat from the oven, no stove top cooking, etc.

Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Pie

A classic with a little twist! This strawberry cheesecake ice cream pie recipe is simple to make, much easier than strawberry cheesecake in my opinion, and it’s perfect for serving up on those hot days of summer.

Still plenty indulgent but a little more smooth and creamy with a cooling effect that we all crave during these dog days of summer!

side view of a slice of strawberry cheesecake ice cream pie ready to serve

4th of July Pie | Coconut Ice Cream Pie

We called this one 4th of July Pie because it’s a red, white, and blue masterpiece but it’s really just a coconut ice cream pie that you can make any time of the year. Of course it’s extra delicious during the summer months when the weather is hot and you need something indulgent but not too heavy.

It’s perfect for sharing at all those summer parties you have lined up for 4th of July, Memorial Day, etc. Give it a try!

Key Lime Ice Cream Pie

If you love key lime pie you have to try this key lime ice cream pie. It’s tart, tangy, creamy, and indulgent all while boasting those flavors we all know and love in a key lime pie.

It’s a simple way to make a key lime pie that doesn’t need a special occasion. Serve it up any time you want a bright, fresh, creamy taste of summer.

Finished key lime ice cream pie

Looking for more dessert collections to check out?

If you are looking for even more delicious ways to stock up your dessert menus you have to check out some of our other recipe collections. We think you’ll love all of these tasty treats!